HOME

CHANCE! - Give Peace a Chance The World After 9.11 Links $B%$%(%m!<%j%\%s%5%$%H%W%m%8%'%/%H!J#N#G#O%M%C%H%o!<%/!K(B
$B!J5l!&JF9q$N%F%mJsI|967b$r;_$a$h$&%j%s%/!K(B

$B%F%m$H$=$NJsI|$K$D$$$F;W$&$3$H(B
$B!J:G=*99?7!'(B2002$BG/(B5$B7n(B5$BF|!K(B

$BE0Dl$7$?JsF;4I@)!&>pJsA`:n$,9T$o$l$?OQ4_@oAh$N;~Be$O%$%s%?!<%M%C%H$O$"$j$^$;$s$G$7$?!#(B
$B$7$+$7:#2s$O%$%s%?!<%M%C%H>e$G!"L>$bCN$i$L$B%^%9%3%_$,=&$o$J$$!J$^$?$OL[;&$9$k!KM-L>L5L>$N$5$^$6$^$J?M!9$N%a%C%;!<%8$,9T$-8r$C$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B$=$N0lJ}$G!":#F|$b%Q%l%9%A%J$H%$%9%i%(%k$G$O!"APJ}$NBg@*$N;TL1$,K=NO$N5>@7$K$J$jB3$1!"(B
$B$=$7$FF|K\$b!"!I%f!<%8%[!<%;!

$B%j%s%/=8!J:G=*99?7!'(B2002$BG/(B5$B7n(B5$BF|!K(B

$B%f!<%8%[!<%;!<4XO"(B

NO WAR! $B%f!<%8%[!<%;!<%W%m%8%'%/%H(B
$B%f!<%8%[!<%;!<$C$FC/!)$C$F!"$=$l$O!VM-;vK!@)!W!#$$$C$?$$$=$l$O2?$J$N$+!)$=$l$,@.N)$7$?$i$I$&$J$k$N$+!)$H$j$"$($:%/%j%C%/!#(B

YUJI$B!!(B*$B!!(BSTORY $BM-;vK!@)$NLdBjE@$r$o$+$j$d$9$/2r@b!JF~$l$J$$$H$-$O(B$B$3$A$i$NF~$j8}(B$B$+$i!K(B

$B%T!<%9!&%K%e!<%9(B$B$N(B$B%"%a%j%+$N@oAh3HBg$HF|K\$NM-;vK!@)$KH?BP$9$k=pL>(B

$B$"$J$?$N$H$J$j$NM-;v(B
$B%f!<%8%[!<%;!<$K4X$9$kAm9g>pJs%5%$%H$G$9(B

$B%"%a%j%+$N@oAh3HBg$HF|K\$NM-;vK!@)$KH?BP$9$k=pL>;vL36I(B

$B%-%c%s%Z!<%s(B

CHANCE! - Give Peace a Chance
$B!!(B$B%a!<%j%s%0%j%9%H#1!'(B CHANCE ! Forum $B$5$^$6$^$J5DO@!"JsF;$J$I$N>pJs6&M-!J%a%C%;!<%88x3+!K(B
$B!!(B$B%a!<%j%s%0%j%9%H#2!'(B CHANCE ! Action $BA49q$N3hF04XO"$N>pJs!J%a%C%;!<%88x3+!K(B
$B!!(B$B5l%a!<%j%s%0%j%9%H!'(B Global Peace 11$B7nKvF|$GJD:?!#2a5n%m%0$O8x3+!#(B
$B!!(B$BA49q%T!<%9%&%)!<%/(BMAP
$B!!(B$B4X@>%T!<%9%$%Y%s%H>pJs!V$+$s$5$$!!$T!<$9!!$3$h$_!W(B

NO WAR! $B%f!<%8%[!<%;!<%W%m%8%'%/%H(B

$B6[5^8F$S$+$1(B!!
$B%"%U%,%K%9%?%s$N$3$I$bC#$K%o%/%A%s@\
$B%a%C%;!<%8MQ7G<(HD(B
$B!X%j%s%/$7$?$h!*!Y@lMQ7G<(HD(B
$B;_$`$3$H$N$J$$6uGz$N$;$$$G!"%"%U%,%s$N;R6!$NM=KI@\l=j$,$"$k$N$@$=$&$G$9!#(B

$B%F%m$K$bJsI|$K$bH?BP(B!! $B;TL16[5^9TF0!VH?@o!&J?OB%"%/%7%g%s!W(B

$B%"%a%j%+$N?7J9$KJ?OB$NA4LL9-9p$r=P$=$&(B Global Peace Campaign $B!J(Bby $B?@8M855$B<(B$B!K(B
John Lennon$B$NCB@8F|$G$"$k(B10$B7n(B9$BF|!"8+;v$K(B$B7G:\(B$B$,3p$$$^$7$?!*!*(B
$B%"%U%,%sFqL15_1g%W%m%8%'%/%H(B: "Forgive, GET PEACE"
$B%"%U%,%s$NFqL1$N?M$?$A$r5_:Q$9$k$?$a$N(BGPC$B$NJg6b%W%m%8%'%/%H(B

$B%$%(%m!<%j%\%s%5%$%H%W%m%8%'%/%H(B (2001.10.15 started.) $B%$%(%m!<%j%\%s%5%$%H%W%m%8%'%/%H!J#N#G#O%M%C%H%o!<%/!K(B

Anti War

$B%+%V!<%k522nBP:v7W2h!V%"%U%,%s!!$$$N$A$N4p6b!W(B $B6[5^(B!! 1984$BG/0JMh!"%"%U%,%s$G?GNE=j$r3+$-!"0f8M$r7!$jB3$1$F$-$?(B$B!V%Z%7%c%o!<%k2q!W(B$B$K$h$k6[5^Jg6b%W%m%8%'%/%H!#%"%U%,%s$G$O:#E_!"?tI4K|?M$,522n$K4Y$j2n;`$9$k4m5!$KD>LL$7$F$$$^$9!#%"%a%j%+$N6uGz$+$iF($l$h$&$H$9$k;TL1$NCOMk$K$h$kHo32u67$G$9!#(B

$BF|K\%f%K%;%U6(2q(B$B!#(B$B9qO";yF84p6b!J(BUNICEF$B!K%"%U%,%sFqL16[5^Jg6b(B$B!#%*%s%i%$%s$GJg6b$G$-$k(B$B%$%s%?!<%M%C%HJg6b(B$B!#(B $B6[5^(B!!
10.22$BD+F|?7J9$K$h$l$P%f%K%;%U$,!V:#E_%"%U%,%s$N;R$I$b(B40$BK|?M;`K4!W$b$"$j$&$k$H$7!"9q:]J,$7$+=8$^$C$F$$$J$$$=$&$G$9!#(B

$B9qO"!&@$3&?)NH7W2h!J(BWFP$B!K(B$B$N(B$B%"%U%,%K%9%?%s6[5^1g=uJg6b$N$*4j$$(B $B6[5^(B!!
$B$*$J$8$/(B10.22$BD+F|?7J9$K$h$l$P!V@$3&?)NH7W2h!J(BWFP$B!K$N>l9g!"(B2$B2/(B5700$BK|%I%k$,I,MW$H;n;;!"$9$G$K(B7000$BK|%I%k$N;q6b$rJ];}$7$F$$$?$,!"$=$N8e(B1500$BK|%I%kDxEY$7$+=8$^$C$F$$$J$$!W$=$&$G$9!#(B

WEB$B=pL>(B

$B%T!<%9!&%K%e!<%9(B$B$N(B$B%"%a%j%+$N@oAh3HBg$HF|K\$NM-;vK!@)$KH?BP$9$k=pL>(B

$B%"%a%j%+$NJsI|@oAh$HF|K\$N;2@o$KH?BP$9$k=pL>1?F0(B $B%"%U%,%s>p@*!"%3%a%s%?%j!

$BBg3X$K$*$1$k8@O@$N<+M3$r$N8F$S$+$1!K(B $BI,FI(B!!
$B$b$H$O(BYahoo! $B7G<(HD(B$B$K9pCN$5$l$?$b$N$r!"Bg:eI\N)Bg$N(B$B?92,@5Gn$5$s(B$B$,(BWEB$B$KE>:\$7$?$b$N!#%"%a%j%+$G!V8@O@!&;WA[?.>r$N<+M3!W$H$$$&4pK\E*?M8"$,!"$=$N:G$b7x8G$J:V$G$"$k$Y$-Bg3X$G$5$(C%$o$l$D$D$"$j$^$9!#!JBg3X$,$3$N<+M3$N:V$@$J$s$F$?$@$NM}A[O@!&7zA0O@$+$b$7$l$J$$$1$I!"$=$l$r

$B!XK=NO$O$b$&$4$a$s$@!*!Y9q:]%"%T!<%k(B ($B%+%J%@(B)$B!!!!(B$B!J(BLena Lindahl$B$5$s$K$h$k>R2p!K(B
$B1Q8l$,6l$B=pL>$N;EJ}$NF|K\8l@bL@(B$B$r$I$&$>!#!J=pL>%Z!<%8$+$i$b$3$A$i$K%j%s%/$5$l$F$^$9!#!K(B

Call For Peace & Justice! ($BJF(B) $B!J(B$BF|K\8l2r@b(B$B!K(B

9-11peace.org ($BJF(B) $B!J(B$BF|K\8l2r@b(B$B!K(B

$B!VJ?OB$HHsK=NO$N@$5*!W$rAO$kL5L>;TL1$N2q(B

$B>pJs%5%$%H(B

Yahoo! $B%K%e!<%9!VBPJF%F%m!&73;vJsI|9TF0!W(B

$B%"%k%8%c%8!<%iJ|Aw(B
$B!VCfEl$N(BCNN$B!W$H$b8F$P$l$k%"%k%8%c%8!<%i!#%"%i%S%"8l$J$N$GFI$`$H$-$O(B$B%"%i%S%"8l"*1Q8lJQ49$N%&%'%V%Z!<%8!?%F%-%9%HK]Lu%5!<%S%9(B$B$rMxMQ$7$^$7$g$&!#(B

$B%F%m;v7o!?JsI|@oAh$X$N8+2r$d
$B4D6-LdBjK]Lu2H(B
$B;^W"=_;R$N(B $B4D6-%H%C%W%Z!<%8(B$B$h$j!#%^%9%3%_$GN.$l$J$$$5$^$6$^$J%a%C%;!<%8=8!#(B

$BBPJF%F%m;v7oJsF;$rAjBP2=$9$k$?$a$K(B$B$H$=$N(B$BBPJF%F%m4XO"7G<(HD(B
$BBg:eI\N)Bg3X$N?92,@5Gn$5$s!J@8L?3X!K$N%5%$%H$G$9!#$3$A$i$N%Z!<%8$b%j%s%/$7$F$$$?$@$$$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B%W%l%^#2#1%M%C%H(B

$BF|K\9q:]%\%i%s%F%#%"%;%s%?!$B$N(B$B!VJ?OB$N$?$a$N%5%$%H!W(B

$B2CF#E/O:$N%M%A%:%s!&%+%l%C%8(B$B$H$=$N(B$B%$%^%8%s(B IMAGINE!$B%Z!<%8(B

$BJ?OB$K8~$1$?%K%e!<%9$rFI$`$?$a$N(BPeaceWeblog

BOOKMARKS $BJF9q%^%5%A%e!<%;%C%D$N%9%_%9%+%l%C%8$GF|K\8l$r65$($F$$$kBg;3$a$0$_$5$s$K$h$k1Q8l%K%e!<%9$rCf?4$K$7$?>pJs%5%$%H!JF|K\8l$GFI$a$^$9!K!#$A$J$_$K$3$N%5%$%H$rCN$C$F$:$C$H8e$KJ,$C$?$N$G$9$,!"H`=w$O>.@8$NBg3X;~Be$N8eGZ$G$7$?!#(B

$BJFF1;~B?H/%F%m4XO"(BINFO$BK]Lu7G<(HD!J1Q!K(B
Yahoo ! $B7G<(HD$rMxMQ$7$F!"1Q8l%K%e!<%9$rF|K\8l$KK]Lu$7$FC_@Q$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B%A%g%`%9%-!<$N%$%s%?%t%e!$BJFF1;~B?H/%F%m4XO"(BINFO$BK]Lu7G<(HD(B$B!K(B
$B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(1), $B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(2), $B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(3)

$B%"%a%j%+F1;~B?H/%F%m$X$NIpNOJsI|$KH?BP$9$k%[!<%`%Z!<%8%j%s%/=8(B

MediaChannel.org ($BJF9q(B)
$BBg%a%G%#%"$,JsF;$7$J$$>pJs$r8x3+$7!"%^%9%a%G%#%"$r4F;k!#(B

Institute for Public Accuracy(IPA): War: Information, Analysis, Policy Options ($BJF9q(B)
$B%^%$%N%j%F%#B&!&H?%0%m!<%P%j%

Independent Media Center$B!JJF9q!K(B $B@$3&Cf$K%;%s%?!<$r;}$D%*!<%k%?%J%F%#%V!&%a%G%#%"!#(B

Inter Action $B!JJF9q!K(B $B;}B3E*3+H/!"?MF;;Y1g$J$I$NJ,Ln$G3hF0$9$k#1#6#5CDBN$NO"9g(BInter Action$B$K$h$k%"%U%,%K%9%?%s$N?MF;E*4m5!>u67$K4X$9$k>pJs!#(B

Pax Protest Net $BJ?OBE*BP=h$r5a$a$k$?$a$N@$3&Cf$N=82q>pJs!#(B

$BF|K\%+%H%j%C%/@55A$HJ?OB6(5D2q(B(Japan Catholic Council for Justice and Peace)
$BJF9q%F%m$H%"%U%,%sJsI|967b4X78%Z!<%8(B
$B!V=w@-C#$N@<$rJ9$1!W(B
$B%N!<%Y%kJ?OB>^%j%4%Y%k%?!&%a%s%A%e%&$+$i%V%C%7%eBgE}NN$X$N
$BCNE*=jM-8"$HC:AD6](B $B%P%$%*%F%mHo32
$B!V%F%m$r4?7^$9$k%Q%l%9%A%J?M$N1GA|!WLdBj$K$D$$$F(B$BOQ4_@oAh$N$H$-$N!V=EL}$^$_$l$ND;!W$N56B$1GA|$HF1MM$K!"$3$N1GA|$b$^$?>pJsA`:n$H$$$&5?$$!#(B

$B8|@8O+F/>J(B
$B!V9qFb$N6[5^%F%mBP:v4X78!W%[!<%`%Z!<%8(B
$B!VJF9q$NF1;~B?H/%F%m4X78!W%[!<%`%Z!<%8(B

$BF|K\0e;U2q46@w>I4m5!4IM}BP:v<
$B%P%$%*%F%m4X78$N>pJs$G$9!#(B

$B9q:]7:;v:[H==j$H$O(B
$B9q:]7:;v:[H==jLdBjF|K\%M%C%H%o!<%/(B(JNICC)$B$K$h$k2r@b!#(B
$B9q:]7:;v:[H==j(B (Int'l Clime Court: ICC)

$B73;v(B&$B0BA4J]>c%j%s%/=8(B (Military & Seculity Link)
$B@oAhK!4XO"(B$B$J$I=<

$B0U8+!&J,@O(B

$B%]%j%m%4%9!&E/3X%/%m%K%/%k(B$B$N(B$B!V(B911$B%F%m;v7oFC=8!W(B $BI,FI(B!!
$B%F%m;v7o$K4X$9$k@$3&$NCN<1?M$NH/8@Ey$,FI$a$^$9!#(B

$B8@8l3X$B$H(B$B%A%g%`%9%-!<$N%$%s%?%t%e!<(B $BI,FI(B!!

$B%A%g%`%9%-!<$N%$%s%?%t%e!$BJFF1;~B?H/%F%m4XO"(BINFO$BK]Lu7G<(HD(B$B!K(B
$B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(1), $B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(2), $B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(3)

$B%A%g%`%9%-! $BI,FI(B!!
$B!!(B
Noam Chomsky Archive

$B%A%g%`%9%-!<(I%$B%$%s%?%S%e!<$NK]Lu!J(Bby $B4tIlBg3X;{Eg8&!K(B

$B%(%I%o!<%I!&%5%$!<%I$NH/8@$=$N(B1$B$H(B$B$=$N(B2 $BI,FI(B!!

$B%Z%k%Y!<%9!&%U%C%I%\!<%$(B $B!V0E9u$N2PMKF|!'%$%9%i%^%P!<%I$+$i!W(B$B!!(B$BI,FI(B!!
9$B7n(B27$BF|!&D+F|?7J9D+4)!JA49qHG!K$KC;=LHG$,7G:\$5$l$?%Q%-%9%?%s$NJ*M}3X$BED:j@2L@$5$s(B$B$i$NK]Lu$G$9!#(B

$B2CF#>0Ip!VO"B3%F%m$KBP$9$kJsI|@oAh$N9q:]K!E*$J@5Ev@-$O@.$jN)$?$J$$!W(B
$B9q:]K!$N4QE@$+$i$NNQM}3X0Ip$5$s$N%"%T!<%k!#(B

$B2,K\??!VBPJFF1;~B?H/%F%m;v7o$r$a$0$kH/?.!W(B
$B!J(BACADEMIC RESOURCE GUIDE [ARG-112]$B!!(B2001$BG/(B10$B7n(B08$BF|!K(B
$B3X2q!&CDBN!&8&5f

$B%N!<%Y%kJ?OB>^%j%4%Y%k%?!&%a%s%A%e%&$+$i%V%C%7%eBgE}NN$X$N
$B%0%"%F%^%i@h=;L13hF02H%a%s%A%e%&$N%a%C%;!<%8!#(B
$BF|K\%+%H%j%C%/@55A$HJ?OB6(5D2q(B$B$,8x3+!#(B

$BEDCf1'$N9q:]%K%e!<%92r@b(B
$B!!(B$B%F%m$N?J9T$rKI$,$J$+$C$?JF73!Z(B2002$BG/(B1$B7n(B28$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B%F%m$r$o$6$HKI$,$J$+$C$?BgE}NN!Z(B2002$BG/(B1$B7n(B24$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B%F%m%j%9%H$N>SA|!Z(B2002$BG/(B1$B7n(B7$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B%=%^%j%"$NOBJ?$r2u$9JF73$N!V@o>lC5$7!W!Z(B2001$BG/(B12$B7n(B24$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$BC:aT6]$H%"%a%j%+$NJsF;!Z(B2001$BG/(B12$B7n(B13$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$BC:aT6]$HJF73!Z(B2001$BG/(B12$B7n(B10$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B%"%a%j%+$G9M$($k!J#1!K!Z(B2001$BG/(B11$B7n(B26$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$BJF1Q$GI|3h$9$k?"L1CO
$B!!(B
$B%*%5%^!&%S%s%i%G%#%s$H#C#I#A$N0&A~4X78!Z(B2001$BG/(B11$B7n(B5$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B%"%a%j%+<+M3
$B!!(B
$B%F%m$N>Z5r$r<($;$J$$%"%a%j%+!Z(B2001$BG/(B10$B7n(B27$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B$h$_$,$($k%Q%7%e%H%K%9%?%s$NK4Nn!Z(B2001$BG/(B10$B7n(B15$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B%"%a%j%+$r=u$1$k%*%5%^!&%S%s%i%G%#%s!Z(B2001$BG/(B9$B7n(B27$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B!V@oAh!W$O%"%a%j%+$r$b$C$HIT9,$K$9$k!Z(B2001$BG/(B9$B7n(B18$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$BJFBg5,LO%F%m$NHH?MA|$r9M$($k!Z(B2001$BG/(B9$B7n(B13$BF|![(B
$B!!(B$B%"%a%j%+$N%F%m;v7o$rFI$`!Z(B2001$BG/(B9$B7n(B11$BF|![(B

$B%"%8%"9q:]DL?.(B$B$N(BNo.230$B!V685$$N!XJ8L@$N>WFM!Y@oN,$O%"%a%j%+$,H/L@$7$?!W(B

$B%S%k!&%H%C%F%s$N%l%?!<(B Our World
$B!!(B$B%a%G%#%"!&%3%s%H%m!<%k(B $B%"%a%j%+$N@oAh$H@$O@A`:n$K$D$$$F$N%A%g%`%9%-!<$N(B93$BG/$N%(%C%;%$!#(B
$B!!(BNo.489 $B@o;~BN@)$NJF9q(B
$B!!(BNo.490 $BK=NO$G$O2r7h$7$J$$(B
$B!!(BNo.491 $B@$3&$+$i1s$6$+$kJF9q(B $BF1;~%F%mD>A0$^$G$K%V%C%7%e@/8"$,9T$C$?@/:v7hDj$NJ,@O!#(B
$B!!(BNo.492 $B%Q!<%k%O!<%P!
$B!!(B
No.496 $B?.$8$,$?$$;vBV$NI,A3@-(B $B1Q9q?M%8%c!<%J%j%9%H$K$h$k(B9.11$B%F%m$NM}M3$NJ,@O!#(B
$B!!(BNo.497 $B967b>J(B $BJF9q?M%3%i%`%K%9%H$K$h$k(B9.11$B%F%m$NM}M3$NJ,@O!#(B
$B!!(BNo.499 $BL58B$N@55A$NBe?t(B $B%$%s%I$N>.@b2H$K$h$kJF9q@/I\$NJ,@O!#(B
$B!!(BNo.501 $B!X@PL}$r=d$kJF9q$NL4!'%+%V!<%k$K2$JFGI@/8"$,
$B!!(B
No.505 $B%0%m!<%P%k2=$H$$$&L>$N@oAh!J(B1$B!K(B
$B!!(BNo.506 $B%0%m!<%P%k2=$H$$$&L>$N@oAh!J(B2$B!K(B
$B!!(BNo.507 $B%0%m!<%P%k2=$H$$$&L>$N@oAh!J(B3$B!K(B

$B%`%_%"!&%"%V!&%8%c%^!<%k!V/$B!V(B9$B7n(B11$BF|$N;v7o$KBP$9$k%`%_%"$N%3%a%s%H!W(B $B%`%_%"$N;`7:<99TDd;_$r5a$a$k;TL1$N2q(B$B$h$j!#(B

$B%k!&%b%s%I!&%G%#%W%m%^%F%#!<%/(B ($BF|K\8l%5%$%H(B) Le Monde Diplomatique (French) $BI,FI(B!!
$B!!(B$B@$3&$N?7$?$JAjKF!J(B2001$BG/(B12$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B@8J*J<4o$H%@%V%k!&%9%?%s%@!<%I!J(B2001$BG/(B11$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B522nLdBj$r$a$0$k9qO"5!4X$NJ,Nv!J(B2001$BG/(B11$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%$%9%i%`@/<#1?F0$NB?MM$JE83+!J(B2001$BG/(B11$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%b%9%/%o$O$J$
$B!!(B
$B$@$l$b$,$_$J%"%a%j%+?M!J(B2001$BG/(B10$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%`%9%j%`$H$7$F!"@$3&;TL1$H$7$F!J(B2001$BG/(B10$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%Q%-%9%?%s$N4m81$J@oN,!J(B2001$BG/(B10$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B!VE(!W$N=P8=!J(B2001$BG/(B10$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%Q%l%9%A%JOBJ?$O$$$+$K$7$FF\:C$7$?$+!J(B2001$BG/(B9$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B!V?MN`$O0l$D!W$OL4$+0-L4$+!J(B2001$BG/(B8$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B!VH?%0%m!<%P%j%
$B!!(B
$BJF9q73;v@oN,$N;0$D$NCl!J(B2001$BG/(B7$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%"%U%,%K%9%?%s$KBP$9$k2$JF$NL7=b@/:v!J(B2001$BG/(B6$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B!VDc6/EYJ6Ah!W$NCO@/3X!J(B2001$BG/(B3$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B>.2P4o$O$$$+$K$7$FJ6AhCO0h$KN.$l9~$`$+!J(B2001$BG/(B1$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%$%i%s@PL}9qM-2=8e$N(BCIA$B$N:vKE!J(B2000$BG/(B10$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B3HBgO)@~$KH?E>$7$?%"%a%j%+$N73;v@oN,!J(B1999$BG/(B12$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B?7$?$J$k@$3&Ca=x!J(B1999$BG/(B6$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B>CHq$9$k!V<+M3!W$N$"$k@$3&!J(B1998$BG/(B8$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B9gM}@-$N$"$/$J$-DI5a(B - $B!V%"%a%j%+$N7P:Q%Q%U%)!<%^%s%9!W$N@5$7$$FI$_J}!J(B1997$BG/(B1$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$BH?%F%m==;z73!J(B1996$BG/(B9$B7n9f!K(B
$B!!(B$B%"%a%j%+$N%3%m%s%S%"Fs=E@/:v(B - $BKcLt$H$$$&%"%j%P%$!J(B1996$BG/(B8$B7n9f!K(B

$B%"%U%,%K%9%?%s>pJs(B

$B;d$b%"%U%,%s$K$D$$$F2?$bCN$j$^$;$s$G$7$?!#$@$+$i$3$=CN$j$^$7$g$&!#(B

$B%U%)%H%8%c!<%J%j%9%H!&9-2ON40l$5$s!'(BHIROPRESS.net$B!J9-2ON40lDL?.!K(B
$B6[5^%&%'%V $B%A%'%k%N%V%$%j86H/;v8N$NHo32$J%U%)%H%8%c!<%J%j%9%H9-2ON40l$5$s$N6[5^%&%'%V

$B8IN)$9$k%"%U%,%s$G?GNE=j$r7z$F!"0f8M$r7!$k!V%Z%7%c%o!<%k2q!W(B
$BF12q$NCfB$B!V8IN)$N%"%U%,%s!W$N5-O?(B$B!#(B$BI,FI(B!!
$B=05D1!5D0w2q4[Js9p2q$G$NCfB<0e;U$N9V1i!V%"%U%,%s$G5/$-$F$$$kK\Ev$N$3$H!W(B $B!J(BACT$B?7J9$BDs6!!K(B

$B%"%U%,%s=w@-$H;R6!$?$A$r;Y1g$9$k2q(B

$B%"%U%,%K%9%?%s9qL1$N8= $B!J(B$B%j%s%/=8(B$B!K(B
$B%"%U%,%K%9%?%s$H%Q%-%9%?%s$KBZ:_7P83$N$"$k4IM}?M$,8l$k%"%U%,%s$N;Q!#!V%?%j%P%s!a=w@-M^05CF05@/8"!W$H$$$&$3$3$N$H$3$mJsF;$,N.$7$F$$$k!=JF9q$N%"%U%,%s967b$N@5Ev2=$C$]$$!=8+J}$K$b0[$r>'$($F$$$^$9!#(B

$B%"%U%,%K%9%?%s(B $B!=(B $BG{$i$l$?
$B4IM}?M[)$/!V$J$s$G$"$l!"FI$s$@$@$1$G9NDj$7$J$$$G$/$@$5$$!#=q$$$F$"$k>pJs$r5?$C$F$/$@$5$$!#FI$s$@$@$1$GH]Dj$7$J$$$G$/$@$5$$!#$4<+J,$,!VCN$C$F!W$$$k>pJs$b5?$C$F$/$@$5$$!W$H$N$3$H!#!V(B
$B=EMW$JCm0U(B - $B;kE@$N$B!W$OI,FI!#(B

$BF|K\!&%"%i%VDL?.(B
$B
$B:a$N$J$$%$%i%/9qL1$K$?$$$9$k7P:Q@):[$N2r=|$r5a$a$k%"%T!<%k(B
$B%5%@%`!&%U%;%$%s$h$j%"%a%j%+$*$h$S@>2$=t9qL1$H$=$N@/I\$X$NBh0l8x3+=q4J(B
$B%"%a%j%+9g=09q$*$h$S@>B&@$3&$N=t9qL1$H@/I\$X!'%5%@%`!&%U%;%$%s$+$i$NBhFs$N8x3+=q4J(B
$BF|K\$b4^$a@>B&=t9q$G$O6K0-?M07$$$N%U%;%$%sBgE}NN$N=q4J!#!V%W%m%Q%,%s%@$@!W$H0l=3$9$k$N$O4JC1$G$9$,!"$A$c$s$HFI$s$G$+$i$K$9$k$Y$-$G$7$g$&!#(B

$BF|!&%QN99T $B%Q%-%9%?%s:_=;$N<+>N!V%*%P%O%s!W$N%l%]!<%H!#(B

$B30L3>J!V%"%U%,%K%9%?%s(BQ&A$B!J(BFAQ$B!K!W(B

$BF|K\@/I\$K$h$k:_F|%"%U%,%sFqL1ITEv<}MFLdBj(B
$BK!L3>J!aK!(B$BL5(B$B>J!J(BMinistry of Injustice$B!K$K$h$k(B$BFqL1>rLs0cH?9T0Y(B

$BF|K\$K$$$k%"%U%,%sFqL1$r8+;&$7$K$7$J$$$G(B!
$B9q2H$K$h$k!VA~0-HH:a!J%X%$%H%/%i%$%`!K!W!'F|K\$N%"%U%,%s>/?tL1B2FqL1?=@A
$B!!(B
$B%"%U%,%sFqL1?=@A
$B!V%"%U%,%s;Y1g!W$H$$$&L>L\$G<+1RBbGIJ<$K855$%7%c%+%j%-$NF|K\@/I\!#$=$N0lJ}$G!">/?tL1B2$H$7$FGw32!&9iLd$r$NFqL1$NJ}!9$,!"ITEv$K<}MF!&94N1$5$l!"0lC6$O2rJ|$5$l$?(B5$BL>$b4^$a$FA40w$K6/@)B`5nL?Na$,=P$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B$B$3$NHsF;$N;EBG$A$OF|K\$bHc=Z$7$F$$$kFqL1>rLs$G6X$8$i$l$F$$$k0cK!9T0Y(B$B$G$9!#(B12$B7n(B19$BF|$KEl5~9b:[$,2<$7$?H=7hM}M3$J$I$O!"FqL1>rLs$NFqL1G'Dj4p=`$H$O(B$BA4$/L54X78(B$B$NG'Dj5Q2<$G$9!#K!L3>J$O$I$&$d$iK!(B$BL5(B$B>J!J(BMinistry of Injustice$B!K$K@.$j2<$,$C$F$7$^$C$?$h$&$G$9!#CQ$:$+$7$$!#(B
CHANCE!$B$N(B$B%a!<%j%s%0%j%9%H(B$B$G$NJs9p!'(B
http://www.freeml.com/ml_view.php?ml=chance-forum&pg=387
http://www.freeml.com/ml_view.php?ml=chance-forum&pg=424
http://www.freeml.com/ml_view.php?ml=chance-forum&pg=435
http://www.freeml.com/ml_view.php?ml=chance-forum&pg=436
http://www.freeml.com/ml_view.php?ml=chance-forum&pg=437

$B%V%C%7%e@/8"$N(B
$B9TF0GX7J(B

$B$"$^$j?

$B%V%C%7%e@/8"$H@PL}Mx8"(B
$BBg:eI\N)Bg$N?92,@5Gn$5$s$N(B$BBPJF%F%m;v7oJsF;$rAjBP2=$9$k$?$a$K(B$B$G8x3+!#(B

$B%,!<%G%#%"%s5-;v!X@PL}$r=d$kJF9q$NL4!'%+%V!<%k$K2$JFGI@/8"$,

$B!V%"%U%,%K%9%?%s@oAh$H@PL}Mx8"!W(Bby$B9q:]LdBjI>O@2H!&KLBtMN;R$5$s(B

$BO*9|$J!V9q1W!J@PL}4k6HMx8"!K!WDI5a$N%V%C%7%e@/8"(B $B0JA0!"JF9q$N5pBg@PL}4k6H%f%N%+%k$N%3%s%5%k%?%s%H$H$7$FD9G/3hF0$r9T$C$F$-$?$7$F$-$?%+%j%k%6!<%I!J(BZalmay Khalilzad)$B$,!"JF9q$N%"%U%,%sFC;H$H$7$FG$L?!#%"%U%,%s$G$N%Q%$%W%i%$%s7z@_$N7o$G!"%?%j%P%s@/8"$H$b:)0U$K$7$F$$$??MJ*!#(B

$BKI1RD#!V%+%9%T3$<~JU=t9q$N%(%M%k%.!<;q8;$r=d$k:G6a$NF08~$K$D$$$F!W(B

$B%V%C%7%e@/8"$H4k6H$H$N$D$J$,$j!J%o!<%k%I%&%)%C%A!&%^%,%8%s!!(B2001$BG/(B7$B!?(B8$B7n9f$h$j!K(B

$BF|K\!&%"%i%VDL?.(B
$B

$B=54)8=Be(BOnline
$B%V%C%7%e$N62$k$Y$-!V>pJsA`:n!W%9%C%QH4$/(B (10$B7n(B27$BF|9f7G:\(B)
$B%V%C%7%e$H(BCIA$B!V1"KE9):n!W$NA4KF(B (11$B7n(B3$BF|9f7G:\(B)

$B!VJF9q$O@$3&$NJ<4o%9!<%Q!<%^!<%1%C%H!W(B$B!J!X%m%5%s%<%k%9!&%?%$%`%:!Y;f!!(B1999$BG/(B10$B7n(B13$BF|!K(B

$B!VOQ4_@oAh$H@PL}Mx8"!W@55A$N$f$/$(!J8eJT!KMx8"9g@o$O@$Be$r1[$($F(B $B#2#0#0#1G/#27n#2#4F|(B

$BJF9q73<{;:6H:GBg$B%m%C%-!<%I!&%^!<%F%#%s
$B2P;v>lE%K@$+$O$?$^$?%^%C%A%]%s%W$+!"%F%m;v7o$GLY$1$F$$$k$N$O$d$O$jJF9q73<{;:6H!#(B
$B!cJ(B
$B$"$l$@$1%"%U%,%s$K7c$7$$967b$7$F$*$$$F!"%i%`%:%U%'%k%H9qKID941$O(B$B!V%S%s%i%G%#%sJa3M$O:$Fq!W(B$B$H$+8@$C$F$k$/$;$K!"24$BC{1_(B$B!#$=$l$C$F!"%F%mBP:v$H$7$F$NHqMQBP8z2L$rA4A3L5;k$7$F$J$$$+!)!J$^$!$b$H$b$HNd@o;~Be$bL5;k$7$F$?$+$i7P:Q%@%a$K$J$C$?$s$@$1$I!#!K7k6I$O8=BeJ8L@$K4s@8$9$k(B$B6b?)$$%Q%i%5%$%H!V73<{;:6H!W(B$B$r0];}$7$?$$$@$1$J$N$+!)F1$83[$rFqL15_:Q$dES>e9qES>e9q1g=u$K2s$7$?$j!"ES>e9q:DL3$ND">C$7J,$H$7$F;H$($P!"C/$,%"%a%j%+$rA~$`$@$m$&$+!#(B

$B%F%m;v7o$GM^05$5$l$k%&%'%V>e$N8@O@$N<+M3(B($B>e(B) $B!J(BHOT WIRED, 10/25$B!K(B
$BJF9q@/I\$O!V<+M3$HL1

$B!V$3$N2F$,%^!<%1%C%H$NJ,4tE@!)!X%b%N!Y(B $B$X$N%7%U%H$r;kLn$K!W(B new$B!V

$BJF73@oAh;v>p(B

$B!V?7J<4o$Nl!W$H$b8F$P$l$kOQ4_@oAh!&%\%9%K%"!&%3%=%\J6Ah!#%"%U%,%s$d!J:F$S!K%$%i%/$GF1$8$3$H$,7+$jJV$5$l$k$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!&!&(B

$B22IB
$B@$3&KG0W%;%s%?!<$N5>@7$B?F6L%F%m9q2H(B$B$H$=$l$,0i$F$?;RJ,%F%m%j%9%H$N(B$BFbNX$b$a(B$B$N5>@7

$B%^%6%j%7%c%j%U$N5T!'(B $B$3$l$OJF1Q73$N@oAhHH:a$@!*%"%`%M%9%F%#$,D4::$rMW5a(B$B!!(B$BJaN:$KBP$9$kA0BeL$J9$N5T;&;v7o!"%8%e%M!<%V6(Dj0cH?$N@oAhHH:a$N5?$$$,$"$j$^$9!#(B$B$A$J$_$KJF9q5D2q$O!"J6Ah2<$G$NHs?MF;9T0Y$KBP$9$k8D?M$N@UG$$rLd$&9q:]7:;v:[H==j!J(BICC$B!K$K$D$$$F!V3$30GI8/$NJFJ<$,ITEv$K07$o$l$k!W$H!"JF9q@/I\$N6(NO$rA4LLE*$K6X$:$k!VJF73MW0wJ]8nK!0F!W$r2D7h$7$^$7$?!#!J$3$l$C$F!"!VJF73$O@oAhHH:a$rHH$7$F$^$9!W$C$FG'$a$F$k$h$&$J$b$N$G$9!#$b$7$+$7$F%^%6%j%7%c%j%U$N7o$HD>7k$7$F$k$N$+$b!#!K(B$BD+F|?7J9(B(12/8)$B$K$h$l$P!"$3$NK!0F$G$O!VAJDIBP>]$+$iJFJ<$,=|30$5$l$k3NLs$,$J$$8B$j!"9qO"$NJ?OB0];}3hF0!J(BPKO$B!K$K;22C$7$J$$"&JF9qNNEZ$G$NA\::3hF0$O6X;_"&(BICC$B>rLs$rHc=Z$7$?9q$KBP$7$F$O!"6&F171N}$b4^$`JF9q$N73;v1g=u$rDd;_"&JFJ<$,@oHHMF5?$G94B+$5$l$?>l9g!"73;v9TF0$r0UL#$9$k!VI,MW$J$"$i$f$kl9g$O!"C%4T$N$?$a!V%O!<%0?/96!W$b$"$j$&$k$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#!J$J$*1QJ)FH$J$I2$=#rLsHc=Z:Q$_$G$9!#!KJF9q$O!"$^$5$K(B$B@$3&0l$N%F%mD6Bg9q(B$B$X$N:dF;$rA4B.$G6n$12<$j$F$k$h$&$G$9!#(B

$B%A%g%`%9%-!<$N%$%s%?%t%e!$BJFF1;~B?H/%F%m4XO"(BINFO$BK]Lu7G<(HD(B$B!K(B
$B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(1), $B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(2), $B%A%g%`%9%-!<%$%s%?%S%e!<(B(3)

$BCf9q?7J9!VCN$i$l$6$k%R%P%/%7%c!'Nt2=%&%i%sCF$N

$B?9=;Bn%[!<%`%Z!<%8(B $B%U%)%H%8%c!<%J%j%9%H?9=;Bn$5$s$N%5%$%H!#8=:_%"%U%,%s
$BNt2=%&%i%sCF$H7P:Q@):[!]OQ4_@oAh8e$N%$%i%/(B
$B%P%k%+%s%7%s%I%m!<%`!'(BNATO$B$,;H$C$?Nt2=%&%i%sCF(B

$BNt2=%&%i%s8&5f2q(B
$BNt2=%&%i%sCF35@b(B
$B!XNt2=%&%i%sCF!Y(B($B?7AR=$!&4FLu!#F|K\I>O@
$BNt2=%&%i%s$N62I]!]OQ4_@oAh$G%"%a%j%+$O2?$r$7$?$+!J%S%G%*%W%l%9!K(B
$BJF9q$N@oAh$K935D$7F|K\$N@oAh$X$N2YC4$KH?BP$9$k(B $BI,FI(B!!

$BH~IM$N2q!VNt2=%&%i%sCFH?BP!W(B$B!VNt2=%&%i%sCF$KD6LTFG$N%W%k%H%K%&%`!&%"%a%j%7%&%`Ey$,:.F~!*!W$OI,FI!#(B

$B%"%8%"9q:]DL?.(B$B$N(BNo.204$B!V!X8mGz!Y$J$s$FK\Ev$K$"$k$N!)!W(B$B$H(B$B!V!X3K$N%4%_!Y$rCO5e>e$K$P$i$^$/

$B!V@o2P$N%$%i%/$+$i$N>W7b%l%]!<%H!'6uGz2<$N%P%0%@%C%I$K$F!W(B $B%$%i%/$N;R$I$bC#$X$N;Y1g3hF0$K7H$o$C$?=w@-$N%l%]!<%H!#(B

$B%X%V%i%$$N4[!&Bh(B2$B9q:]LdBj8&5f<<(B$B$N(B$BOQ4_@oAh$NN"IqBf!&>e(B$B$H(B$BOQ4_@oAh$NN"IqBf!&2<(B$B$H(B$B%"%a%j%+

Hot Wired News Collection$B!VJF9qF1;~B?H/%F%m!W(B
$B%"%U%,%s967b$KHw$($k!)(B $BJF73:G?71TJ<4o(B($B>e(B)
$B%"%U%,%s967b$KHw$($k!)(B $BJF73:G?71TJ<4o(B($B2<(B)
$BJF9q$OCOI=4SDL7?3KGzCF$r%"%U%,%K%9%?%s$KEj2<$9$k$+!)(B($B>e(B)
$BJF9q$OCOI=4SDL7?3KGzCF$r%"%U%,%K%9%?%s$KEj2<$9$k$+!)(B($B2<(B)
$B%"%U%,%s6uGz$GCO2<;\@_GK2uMQ$NJ<4o%P%s%+!<%P%9%?!$B3KGzCF(BB61-11$B$,!Vo$NGzLt$r;H$C$F$$$^$9$,!"!V$*$b$j!W$H$7$FNt2=%&%i%s$,;H$o$l$F$$$^$9!#(B

B61-11$B$N7|G0$HGX7J(B (B61-11 Concerns and Background)

$B%P%s%+!<%P%9%?!<$H3KGzCF(B

$B%/%i%9%?! $B$9$G$K:#2s$N%"%U%,%s967b$G!"%P%s%+!<%P%9%?!<$H$H$b$K;HMQ$5$l$F$$$^$9!#$3$NGzCF$,$P$i$^$/$?$/$5$s$N>.7?$NGzCF!J;RGzCF!K$N$J$+$K$OITH/CF$bB?$$$?$a!"$9$G$KCOMk$@$i$1$N%"%U%,%s$NBgCO$K?7$?$J!VCOMk86!W$r$D$/$j=P$7$F$*$j!"Hs?MF;J<4o$H$7$FCOMk=|5n(BNGO$B$d9q:]@V==;z$,;HMQ6X;_$rAJ$($F$$$^$9!#(B

BBC$B$K$h$k%/%i%9%?!

When Toys Kill.. $B!J9q:]@V==;z!K(B $B%3%=%\$G;HMQ$5$l$?%/%i%9%?!e$2$?;R6!$?$A;`=}$7$?$=$&$G$9!#$A$J$_$K(B10$B7n(B24$BF|$N9q2qEzJ[$G!"JF73$,%"%U%,%s967b$G$b!"$3$N$h$&$J@o8e$^$GHa7`$r;D$9L5:9JL;&Y$J<4o$G$"$k%/%i%9%?!.@t

$BCOMkGQ@dF|K\%-%c%s%Z!<%s!J(BJCBL$B!K(B$B$K$h$k%/%i%9%?! $B:#F|Mn$H$7!"L@F|;&$9!#(B
$B!V%/%i%9%?!
$B!V%/%i%9%?!

$B9q:]>rLs0cH?$NHs?MF;J<4o%/%i%9%?!

$BG3NA5$2=GzCF(B 11$B7n(B4$BF|0J9_$N6uGz$G!"$3$l$b$H$&$H$&;H$o$l;O$a$F$7$^$C$?$h$&$G$9!#9qO"?M8">.0Q0w2q$,Hs?MF;J<4o$H$7$FHsFq$7$F$$$kJ<4o$N0l$D$G$9!#!J%/%i%9%?!e@o$G$O$9$G$KNt2=%&%i%sCJ$b;H$o$l$F$$$k2DG=@-$,$"$j$^$9!#$B3KGzCF%P%s%+!<%P%9%?!<(BB61-11$B$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!#(B
$B%"%U%,%s$K:GBg5iGzCFEj2<(B
$BDL>oJ<4o:GBg$N#B#L#U#8#2GzCF$r=iEj2<(B
$BOQ4_@oAh$G5$2=GzCF$,;H$o$l$?$H$-$N!V;`$N%O%$%&%'!u!J $B%/%&%'!<%H$+$iF[Av$9$k%$%i%/73$rDI$$$+$1$FB??t$NL14V?M$4$H>F$-J'$C$?CO9v3(?^!#(B
$BNt2=%&%i%s8&5f2q;3:j;a$K$h$k2r@b(B

$B73;v%"%J%j%9%H?@1:85>4;a$N!VF|K\73;v>pJs%;%s%?!

$B!V%^%6%j%7%c%j%U$N5T;&!W$3$l$OJF1Q73$N@oAhHH:a$@!*%"%`%M%9%F%#$,D4::$rMW5a(B$B!J(B$B%"%a%j%+$NJsI|@oAh$HF|K\$N;2@o$KH?BP$9$k=pL>1?F0(B$B!K(B$BJaN:$KBP$9$kA0BeL$J9$N5T;&;v7o!"%8%e%M!<%V6(Dj0cH?$N@oAhHH:a$N5?$$$,$"$j$^$9!#(B $B$A$J$_$KJF9q5D2q$O!"J6Ah2<$G$NHs?MF;9T0Y$KBP$9$k8D?M$N@UG$$rLd$&9q:]7:;v:[H==j!J(BICC$B!K$K$D$$$F!V3$30GI8/$NJFJ<$,ITEv$K07$o$l$k!W$H!"JF9q@/I\$N6(NO$rA4LLE*$K6X$:$k!VJF73MW0wJ]8nK!0F!W$r2D7h$7$^$7$?!#!J$3$l$C$F!"!VJF73$O@oAhHH:a$rHH$7$F$^$9!W$C$FG'$a$F$k$h$&$J$b$N$G$9!#$b$7$+$7$F%^%6%j%7%c%j%U$N7o$HD>7k$7$F$k$N$+$b!#!K(B$BD+F|?7J9(B(12/8)$B$K$h$l$P!"$3$NK!0F$G$O!VAJDIBP>]$+$iJFJ<$,=|30$5$l$k3NLs$,$J$$8B$j!"9qO"$NJ?OB0];}3hF0!J(BPKO$B!K$K;22C$7$J$$"&JF9qNNEZ$G$NA\::3hF0$O6X;_"&(BICC$B>rLs$rHc=Z$7$?9q$KBP$7$F$O!"6&F171N}$b4^$`JF9q$N73;v1g=u$rDd;_"&JFJ<$,@oHHMF5?$G94B+$5$l$?>l9g!"73;v9TF0$r0UL#$9$k!VI,MW$J$"$i$f$kl9g$O!"C%4T$N$?$a!V%O!<%0?/96!W$b$"$j$&$k$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#!J$J$*1QJ)FH$J$I2$=#rLsHc=Z:Q$_$G$9!#!KJF9q$O!"$^$5$K(B$B@$3&0l$N%F%mD6Bg9q(B$B$X$N:dF;$rA4B.$G6n$12<$j$F$k$h$&$G$9!#(B

$B0J2<$OI,FI4XO"J88%(B

$B%i%`%<%$!&%/%i!<%/!XHo9p%8%g!<%8!&%V%C%7%eM-:a!'9q:]@oAhHH:aK!Dn$X$N9pH/>u!Y(B
$B%i%`%<%$!&%/%i!<%/!X%i%`%
$B%i%`%<%$!&%/%i!<%/!X%"%a%j%+$N@oAhHH:a!Y(B

$B%N!<%`!&%A%g%`%9%-! $BK\$NBS$+$i!'!V%"%a%j%+$KJsI|$9$k;q3J$O$J$$!*:#2s$N<+Gz%F%m$O!VJ8L@$N>WFM!W$J$I$G$O$J$$!#$3$N<+Gz%F%m$O!V%F%m9q2H$N?F6L!W$KBP$9$kJL$N=8CD$ND)@o$@!*%"%a%j%+$NCN@-$,6[5^H/8@!W(B

1980$BG/Be$N%K%+%i%0%"$OJF9q$K$h$kK=NOE*$J967b$rLX$C$?!#2?K|$H$$$&?M!9$,;`$s$@!#9q$O$A$K967b$r%(%9%+%l!<%H$5$;$k$3$H$G1~$8$?!#$=$3$G%K%+%i%0%"$O0BA4J]>cM};v2q$KAJ$($?!#M};v2q$O!"$9$Y$F$N9q2H$,9q:]K!$r=ee7G=q$h$j0zMQ!K(B

$B7G<(HD(B($B5~ET6aJU(B)

Give Peace a Chance! $B%F%m$b@oAh$b7y$d!*%"%[$OCO5e$r5_$&!#4X@>?M8rN.7G<(HD(B

ZATTA-YA$B!V%_%5%$%k$d$N$&$FJ?OB$r4j$&J8;z$rBG$A9~$a(B!!$B!WF~8}(B

$B%F%m$b@oAh$b$4$a$s$@!*!!5~ET;TL1%M%C%H%o!<%/(B$B$H$=$N(B$B7G<(HD(B

$B4X@>%T!<%9%$%Y%s%H>pJs!V$+$s$5$$!!$T!<$9!!$3$h$_!W(B $B4X@>?MI,8+(B!!

$B%F%m$H$=$NJsI|$K$D$$$F;W$&$3$H(B

(11)

$B%f!<%8%[!<%;!

$B$[$s$H$O$3$s$J$H$3$K=q$$$F$$$k%R%^$O$J$$$s$@$1$I!&!&(B

$B$G$b!"$3$l$O!"2?$r$5$F$*$-!"=q$$$F$*$+$J$-$c$J$i$sOC$G$9!#$O$C$-$j$$$C$F!"L}CG$7$F$^$7$?$o!#$3$s$J$3$H$K$J$C$F$k$J$s$F!&!&!&(B

$B$^$:$O!":rF|$ND+F|?7J9$N%K%e!<%95-;v(B$B!V%F%mBP:v!"KI1RD#$,L14V?MGI8/$rMW@A!!@PGE$J$I$B!J"+$3$N%j%s%/$O?tF|$G@Z$l$^$9!K!#$=$l$K$h$k$H!"(B

$B@o;~$NBPJF;Y1g$H$7$F%$%s%IMN<~JU$KGI8/$5$l$F$$$k<+1RBb4ODz$d9R6u5!$r=$M}$9$k$?$a!"KI1RD#$,!V@P@nEgGEKa=E9)6H!W!JK\$B:rG/#1#07n$K@.N)$7$?%F%mBP:vFCJLAc$r$a$0$C$FO@5D$r8F$S$=$&$@!#(B

$BMW$9$k$K!"%f!<%8%[!<%;!

$B$G!"$D$$$G$K$$$&$H!"e$ND+F|$N5-;v$O4V0c$$$,$"$j$^$9!#$=$l$O#2CJMn$a$N!V$N?&6H$G$b$9$G$K!VD'MQ=`Hw!W$O;O$^$C$F$k$i$7$$$N$G$9!#(B

$B0J2<$N0O$_$O!":rG/$N(B9$B7n(B11$BF|%F%m$r$-$C$+$1$K;O$^$C$?!"%5%h%/$H$+4{@.$N1?F0$H$OA4$/L51o$@$C$?%U%D!<$N$*$P$5$s!"$*$8$5$s!"$*$M$($A$c$s!"$*$K$$$A$c$s$?$A$N!J"+>.@8$O$=$&$$$&%N%j$,$9$-(B$B!K%M%C%H%o!<%/(BCHANCE!$B$+$i@8$^$l$?%W%m%8%'%/%H$N0l$D(B$B!V(BNO WAR! $B%f!<%8%[!<%;!<%W%m%8%'%/%H!W(B$B$,!"(B3$B7nKv$K(BCHANCE!$B%+%U%'$H$$$&%$%Y%s%H$G!"M-;vK!@)$K$D$$$F$N3X=,!&F$O@2q$rEl5~!&=BC+$N(Bcafe bar$B$G3+$-!J"+$3$&$$$&%;%s%9$b$9$-!K!"$=$l$K>7$+$l$?A%0w$5$s!"4G8nIX$5$s!"%Q%$%m%C%H$5$s$?$A$NOC$+$i$NH4?h$G$9!#(B

$BA4J8$O!"(B$B%a!<%j%s%0%j%9%H(BCHANCE ! Forum$B$N5-;v(B$BM-;vK!@)!&8=>l$N@$B$GFI$a$^$9!#$"$H!"(B$B!V(BNO WAR! $B%f!<%8%[!<%;!<%W%m%8%'%/%H!W(B$B$N%5%$%H$K$"$k!V%f!<%8%[!<%;!<$,$o$+$kL!2h%7%j!<%:!!(B$BBh#1CF(B$B!&(B$BBh#2CF(B$B!&(B$BBh#3CF(B$B!W$OI,8+$G$9!#$^$?(BYUJI$B!!(B*$B!!(BSTORY $B$b$*A&$a!#$=$l$H!"(B$B%T!<%9!&%K%e!<%9(B$B$N(B$B%"%a%j%+$N@oAh3HBg$HF|K\$NM-;vK!@)$KH?BP$9$k=pL>(B$B$N2r@b$b$o$+$j$d$9$$!#(B$B$"$J$?$N$H$J$j$NM-;v(B$B$O%f!<%8%[!<%;!<$K4X$9$kAm9g>pJs%5%$%H$G$9!#MW$9$k$K%f!<%8%[!<%;!<$H$$$&$N$O!"8=:_$N9q:]@/<#>u67$r9M$($k$H!"!VB>9q$+$i$N?/N,$KHw$($k!WK!N'$8$c$J$/$F!"%$%i%/$dKLD+A/$r!V0-$N?u<4!W$HL>;X$7$F@oAh$7$?$/$F%&%:%&%:$7$F$$$k%"%a%j%+$,!"$$$6@oAh;O$a$k$H$-$KF|K\$,%9%`!<%:$K@oAh6(NO$G$-$k$?$a$N!VB>9q$r967b$9$k$N$KHw$($k!WK!N'$@$H$$$&$3$H!#2>$K!VF|K\$r]$H$J$k!J$=$N0UL#$GF|K\$,967b$5$l$k!K!W"*!VF|K\$r]$K$J$j@oAh$K4,$-9~$^$l$k%j%9%/$r9b$a$k$@$1$@$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#3N$+$K!"2?$i$+$NB>9q$+$i$NIpNO967b$KBP$7Hw$(!=!=$=$l$O73;vE*$J$3$H$@$1$G$O$"$j$^$;$s$,!=!=$r$7!"73;vLL$G$NJ8L1E}@)$r$I$&$d$k$+!"F|K\9qL1$d:_F|309q?M!J$H$/$K8r@o9q$N?M$?$A!K$r$I$&J]8n$9$k$+$J$I$NK!E*OHAH$_$r:n$C$F$*$/$N$OI,MW$@$1$l$I!"$H$K$+$/:#:n$i$l$h$&$H$7$F$$$k$d$D$O!"@53N$K$O!V%"%a%j%+@oAh6(NOK!!W$G$7$+$J$$$N$G!"@dBP$KK!0F$rDL2a$5$;$F$O$J$i$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B3$0wAH9g$NJ}$NOC(B

$B$B$3$l$^$G$O!!J6AhEv;v9q$G$J$$$H$$$&(B $B$3$H$GLH$l$?Mh$?4m5!$b!!:#8eM-;vK!@)$,$H$*$C$F(B $B$B!&!&!&(B

$B3$$N>e$K$O!!9q6-$,$J$$$h$&$K!"$3$3$^$G$,A0@~$G!!$3$3$+$i$,8eJ}@o@~(B $B$H$$$&$h$&$J@~0z$-$O$"$j$^$;$s!#$@$+$i!"A%0w$N?M$K$H$C$F$O(B $B9q2q$G>o$K7+$jJV$5$l$k!!8eJ};Y1g$J$i$$$$$H$+0-$$$H$+$$$C$?5DO@$O$^$C$?$/(B $B0UL#$,$J$$$H8@$C$F$$$^$7$?!#(B

$B#2#0Be$NF|@V$N4G8nIX$5$s$NOC(B

$B4G8nIX$5$s$N4V$G$O!!:#2s$NK!N'$N$3$H$O7k9=?<9o$K$B4G8nIX$O$b$H$b$H?M$NL?$r5_$&$?$a$N;E;v$G$9$,!"(B $B!{!{$5$s$$$o$/!!<+J,$,=u$1$?L?$,!!%^%??7$?$J!!;&Y$$r@8$`$N$O(B $B4G8nIX$H$7$F$N<+J,$?$A$N!!;E;v$N:,44$r!!GK2u$9$k$b$N$@$H$$$C$F$$$^$7$?!#(B

$B#1#9#9#8G/$+$i!!7}=F$dCOMk$G$N!!2x2f$KBP1~$9$k$?$a$N!!8&=$$,9T$o$l$F$$$k$h$&(B $B$G$9!#(B $B$3$l$O!"3$30$G$NJ6AhCO$KIk$/>l9g$N$?$a!!$H$$$&LL$b$"$k$h$&$G$9$,!"(B $BF|@V$O$=$b$=$b!!@oCO$G!!E(L#J}$J$/!!J<;N$r4G$k$?$a$K@8$^$l$?AH?%$@$C$?$h$&(B $B$G!"(B $B:#8e!"u67$K$J$C$?$i$B!&!&!&(B

$B$^$?!"M-;v$K$O8=:_IB1!$K$$$k?MC#$r!!DI$$=P$7$F(B $B?7$7$/1?$P$l$F$/$k!!J]$+$i$O$:$5$l$?$j!!8e2s$7$K$5$l$k$3$H$b(B $B$"$k$H$$$C$F$$$^$7$?!#(B

$B85<+1R41$N9R6uO+AH$NJ}$NOC(B

$B!{!{$5$s$O%Y%F%i%s%Q%$%m%C%H$G$"$j$J$,$i!!85<+1R41$H$$$&(B $BJQ$o$C$?7PNr$NJ}$G$9!#(B $B$$$o$P!"9qKI$r;V$7$F!"ESCf$G$=$NL7=bE@$r46$8$FG:$s$G(B $B<+1R41$r<-$a$?$=$&$G$9!#(B $B<+1R41;~Be!!KhD+!!!X9qL1$r$^$b$k$?$a$K!&!&!Y(B $B$H@k@@$r$5$;$i$l$?$=$&$G$9$,!"(B $B$=$&$$$C$?$=$P$+$i!!Ev;~$O0BJ]F.Ah$G!!4pCO$N30$N;TL1$K8~$1$F(B $B=F$r9=$($kKhF|$@$C$?$=$&$G$9!#(B $B0lBN2?$N$?$a$K!!<+J,$O<+1RBb$K$J$C$?$N$+!)G:$s$G7k6I$d$a$?$H$$$C$F$$$^$7$?!#(B

$B!&!&!&(B

$BL14V$NHt9T5!$O!!J<4o$r1?$s$@$j!"J<;N$r$7$F$O$$$1$J$$$H$$$&9q:]E*$J $B$7$+$7!"F|K\$G$O#1#9#9#8G/$K!!:_F|JF73$,!!J<;N$HJ<4o$r1?$V$?$a$K(B $BA4F|6u$NHt9T5!$r%A%c!<%?!<$7$?$=$&$G$9!#(B
$B$3$l$K$O!{!{$5$s$+$J$jE\$C$F$$$^$7$?!#(B $B$3$l$O$"$C$F$O$J$i$J$$$3$H$G!"(B $BL14V5!$OJ<4o$J$I$r1?$P$J$$$H$$$& $B$7$+$7!"L14V5!$,J<4o$r1?$s$G$$$k2DG=@-$,$"$k$H$$$&$3$H$K$J$l$P(B $B$I$s$I$sA@$o$l$F!!:#8e$$$/$i$G$b%F%m$,5/$3$k2DG=@-$,$"$k$H$$$C$F$$$^$7$?!#(B $B6u$N0BA4!">h5R$N0BA4$r$B$7$+$7!"M-;vK!@)$G$O!!9R6u4X78l9g$OH3B'5,Dj$G!!BaJa$5(B $B$l$k2DG=@-$,$"$j!"@dBP$K$3$NK!N'$O$H$a$k$Y$-$@$H$$$C$F$$$^$7$?!#(B

$B$$$A$P$sLLGr$+$C$?$N$O(B $Be41$NL?Na0J30$G$OF0$-$^$;$s!#9qL10l?M0l?M$r$BJ[8n;N$5$s$NOC(B

$BF|K\9qFb$N73<{;:6H$G$"$k!!;0I)=E9)$H$+@P@nEgGEKa$H$+$G(B $BJ<4o$N@=B$$r9T$C$F$$$kItLg$G$O$4$/$4$/:G6a$K$J$C$F(B $B$b$7!"<+1RBb$,Ik$$$F$$$C$?@oCO$G!!J<4o$,8N>c$7$?$H$-$K(B $BD>$9$?$a$KGI8/$5$l$kM=Dj$N5;=Q$B$3$l$OD9$i$/J<4o$r:n$C$F$-$?$3$l$i$N2q$BA*$P$l$k$N$OAH9gLdBj$K$J$j$K$/$$!!Cf7x$N!!4IM}?&$J$I$,$J$C$F$$$k$h$&$G$9!#(B $B$3$3$G$bM-;v$,$+$J$j8=

$B:G8e$NJ[8n;N$5$s$NOC$O!"D+F|$N5-;v$r0l7n0J>e$b@h9T$7$F$$$kOC$G$9!#(B

$BK?$K@/8"MB$1$F$k4V$K!"$3$N%6%^$G$9!#KM$i$N%K%C%]%s$O!#!#!#(B


$B$*$^$1!#(B

$B$U$H!";W$$=P$7$?2N;l!#%V%k!<%O!<%D$N(BTRAIN-TRAIN$B$+$i!#(B

$B8+$($J$$<+M3$,$[$7$/$F(B
$B8+$($J$$=F$r7b$A$^$/$k(B
$BK\Ev$N@<$rJ9$+$;$F$*$/$l$h(B

$B@; $B$@$+$iKM$O2N$&$s$@$h@:0lGU$G$+$$@<$G(B


$B$*$^$1!"$=$N#2!J(B2002.5.6$B!K(B

5$B7n(B6$BF|$N!XD+F|?7J9!Y$N%K%e!<%9!#$3$l$b$H$s$G$b$J$$!#3$Kk$,(B$B%d%i%;(B$B$C$F!"$=$l$C$F$$$o$f$k(B$B!V73It$NFHAv!W(B$B$8$c$J$$$N$+!*!)(B

$B!V%$!<%8%94OGI8/!"3$Kk$,JF73$KN"9):n!!BPF|MW@A$rB%$9!W(B
$BKI1RD#3$>eKkN=4FIt!J3$Kk!K$N44It$,#47n#1#0F|!":_F|JF3$73$N%A%c%W%j%s;JNa41$r2#?\2l4pCO$K(B $BK,$M!"3$>e<+1RBb$N%$!<%8%94O$d#P#3#C>%2|5!$N%$%s%IMNGI8/$rJFB&$+$iMW@A$9$k$h$&F/$-$+$1$F$$(B $B$?$3$H$,$o$+$C$?!#JF@/I\$,$=$N8eF|K\B&$K;}$A$+$1$?GI8/MW@A$NN"B&$K!"3$Kk44It$N9):n$,B8:_$7(B $B$?7A$K$J$k!#JF73;Y1g$r$a$0$k@)I~AH$NFHAv$H$b$$$($k;vBV$G!"J8L1E}@)!J%7%S%j%"%s%3%s%H%m!<(B $B%k!K$N4m$&$$8=>u$,Ib$-D&$j$K$J$C$?!#O"5YL@$1$NM-;vK!@)4XO"K!0F$N9q2q?35D$K$b1F6A$rM?$($=$&(B $B$@!#(B
$B!&!&!&(B
$BJF73;v6Z$O$^$?!"$3$N3$Kk44It$,F/$-$+$1$NM}M3$H$7$F!V2>$KJF73$,BP%$%i%/3+@o$KF'$_@Z$C$F$7(B $B$^$C$F$+$i$G$O!"%$!<%8%94O$d#P#3#C$NGI8/$OFq$7$/$J$k!#(B$B2?$b$J$$$&$A$K=P$7$F$*$1$P!"3+@o$K$J$C$F$bLdBj$K$J$i$J$$$@$m$&(B$B!W$H@bL@$7$?$3$H$bL@$i$+$K$7$?!#(B

2002.5.5


(10)

$BO*9|$J!V9q1W!J@PL}4k6HMx8"!K!WDI5a$N%V%C%7%e@/8"(B

$B$^$?$^$?$d$C$F$/$l$^$7$?%V%C%7%e7/!#(BODA$BMx8"$rlE$kF|K\$N<+L1E^K?308rB25D0w$J$s$+2D0&$/;W$($F$7$^$$$^$9!#0J2<$N0O$_$O!"%a!<%j%s%0%j%9%H(BCHANCE ! Forum$B$GN.$l$F$-$?>pJs$G$9!#(B

$B!!0JA0!"JF9q$N5pBg@PL}4k6H%f%N%+%k$N%3%s%5%k%?%s%H$H$7$FD9G/3hF0$r9T$C$F$-$?$7$F$-$?%+%j%k%6!<%I!J(BZalmay Khalilzad)$B$,!"JF9q$N%"%U%,%sFC;H$H$7$FG$L?$5$l$^$7$?!#H`$O!"JF9q5D2q$d$=$NB>@/I\5!4X$KBP$7!"JF9q@PL}6H3&$N0U8~$r2!$7DL$9$?$a$K3hH/$J3hF0$r9T$C$F$$$??MJ*$G$9!#(B

$B!!%?%j%P%s$N?M8"?/32$,LdBj$H$J$C$F$+$i$b!"Hs>o$K%?%j%P%s4s$j$ND$r9T$C$F$$$^$7$?!#%/%j%s%H%s@/8"$O%?%j%P%s@/8"$rHcH=$9$k0lJ}!"%Q%$%W%i%$%s7z@_$K$D$$$F$O8r>D$rB3$1$F$$$?$3$H$K$J$j$^$9!#(B

$B!!%f%N%+%k$O!"$3$l$^$G$K$b%?%j%P%s@/8"$N44It$rJF9q%F%-%5%9$K>7BT$7!"@\BT7s8r>D$r9T$C$F$$$^$9!#%+%j%k%6!<%I$O$3$N8r>DC4Ev$G$7$?!#(B

$B!!Cf1{%"%8%"$K$*$1$kJF9q$N@PL}$r$a$0$k3hF0$O!"#8#0G/Be=iF,$+$iHs>o$K3hH/$K9T$o$l$F$$$^$7$?!#%+%j%k%6!<%I<+?.$b#8#0G/Be!"%l!<%,%s@/8";~$h$j!"JF9q$N@/:v$D$$$F!"6/$$1F6ANO$r9T;H$7$F$-$^$7$?!#%=%S%(%H$K$h$k%"%U%,%s?/96;~!"%9%F%#%s%,!<$J$I!"COBP6u%_%5%$%kEy!"Ev;~$N:G?7J<4oM"=P$r6/$/?d$7?J$a$?#1?M$G$b$"$j$^$9(B?

$B!!:#2s!"H`$NG$L?$O9q2H0BA4J]>cM};v2q$rDL$8$?$b$N$G!"$=$N>l9g5D2q$N>5G'$OI,MW$J$/$J$j$^$9!#$D$^$j!"H`$,2a5n$K4X78$7$F$$$?LdBj$K$D$$$F!"5D2q$K$h$kD4::Ey$,9T$o$l$k2DG=@-$ODc$$$H;W$o$l$^$9!#(B

$B!!(B $B!!8=:_$N%V%C%7%e@/8"44It$NB?$/$O!"@PL}6H3&$H7R$,$j$N?<$$?M4V$G$9!#%j%A%c!<%I!&%"!<%_%F!<%89qL3I{D941$b%+%j%k%6!<%I$HF1MM!"#1#9#9#7G/:"$+$i%f%N%+%k$H7@Ls$7$F$$$??MJ*$G$9!#$^$?!"9q2H0BA4J]>cC4EvBgE}NNJd:441$N%3%s%I%j!<%6!&%i%$%9$O%7%'%V%m%s!JJF9q$N5pBg@PL}4k6H!#:G6a%F%-%5%3$H$N9gJ;$rH/I=$7$^$7$?!K$NLr0w$G$7$?!#B>$K$b!"%8%g!<%8!&%V%C%7%eBgE}NN!"%A%'%$%K!=P;q$K$h$k%7%s%/%?%s%/=P?H!K!"%I%J%k%I!&%(%t%!%s%9>&L3D941!JA0%H%`!&%V%i%&%s#C#E#O!K$J$I!"B?$/$N%a%s%P!<$,5s$2$i$l$^$9!#(B

$B!!%f%N%+%k$=$NB>$N@PL}4k6H$O!"%"%U%,%s$N>p@*$,0BDj2=$9$k$^$G%"%U%,%s$K$*$1$k3hF0$r0l;~Dd;_$9$k$3$H$rH/I=$7$F$*$j!"%+%j%k%6!<%IG$L?$O%"%U%,%s$G$N?7@/8"$K8F1~$9$k$+$?$A$GJF9q$N?7$?$J@PL}Mx8"3MF@$KNO$rF~$l$F$$$k%V%C%7%e@/8"$N0U8~$K4p$E$$$??MA*$G$"$C$?$H;W$o$l$^$9!#:#8e!"%"%U%,%s$K$*$1$k2a5n$N?M8"?/32$K$D$$$F$N??Aj5fL@$d!"@PL}$K4XO"$7$?4D6-LdBj$J$I$KBP$9$k/$J$+$i$:1F6A$,$"$k$N$G$O$J$$$+$H;W$o$l$^$9!#(B

$B0J2pJs$X$N%j%s%/$G$9!#(B

$B!VBg4k6H$O%9%H%i%$%/2?EY5v$5$l$k!*!)%f%N%+%k$N>l9g!W(B($B%3!<%]%l%$%H%&%)%C%A(B)

$B9q2H0BA4J]>cC4EvBgE}NNJd:441$N%3%s%I%j!<%6!&%i%$%9$,Lr0w$rL3$a$F$$$?@PL}4k6H%7%'%V%m%s!'(B
$B!V%7%'%V%m%s$H@PL}$N4D6-$X$N%$%s%Q%/%H!W(B($B%3!<%]%l%$%H%&%)%C%A(B)

$B%A%'%$%K!l9g!'(B
$B!V%S%k%^$N?M8"?/32$H%A%'%$%K!<;a!W(B

$B%V%C%7%e@/8"$H@PL}Mx8"(B
$BBg:eI\N)Bg$N?92,@5Gn$5$s$N(B$BBPJF%F%m;v7oJsF;$rAjBP2=$9$k$?$a$K(B$B$G8x3+!#(B

$B%,!<%G%#%"%s5-;v!X@PL}$r=d$kJF9q$NL4!'%+%V!<%k$K2$JFGI@/8"$,

$B!V%"%U%,%K%9%?%s@oAh$H@PL}Mx8"!W(Bby$B9q:]LdBjI>O@2H!&KLBtMN;R$5$s(B

$BKI1RD#!V%+%9%T3$<~JU=t9q$N%(%M%k%.!<;q8;$r=d$k:G6a$NF08~$K$D$$$F!W(B

$B%V%C%7%e@/8"$H4k6H$H$N$D$J$,$j!J%o!<%k%I%&%)%C%A!&%^%,%8%s!!(B2001$BG/(B7$B!?(B8$B7n9f$h$j!K(B

2002.2.2


(9)

$B!V>.@n!"$b$&0lEY!"7/$H5DO@$,$7$?$$!W(B

$B%F%m;v7o$+$iAa(B7$B=54V!#:#F|$G(B10$B7n$b=*$o$k!#(B

$B0JA0!"=q$$$?$h$&$K(B$B!":#2s$N%F%m;v7o$K$OKM$NBg3X;~Be$NM'?M$,4,$-9~$^$l$^$7$?!#LnB

$B;v7o8e$9$0$+$i!"H`$,Bg3X;~Be=;$s$G$$$?N@@8$rCf?4$K!"O"Mm$HH`$N1|$5$s$r;Y$($k%M%C%H%o!<%/$,:n$i$l!"H`$H$O%;%/%7%g%s!&%a%$%H$@$C$?KM$N$H$3$m$K$b;~@^!"6a67$,EA$($i$l$F$-$^$9!#!J!V%;%/%7%g%s!W$H$O!"(BICU($B9q:]4pFD65Bg3X(B)$BFHFC$N0lG/$N$H$-$N1Q8l=8Cf%W%m%0%i%`(BFEP$B!=!=(BFreshman English Program$B!=!=$N%/%i%9$N$3$H!#!K(B

$B:G6aFO$$$?$=$N%a!<%k$K!"H`$NN@$G$N@hGZ$@$C$?DE:jM[0l$5$s$NO$,$"$j$^$7$?!#(B

$B!V>.@n!"$b$&0lEY!"7/$H5DO@$,$7$?$$!W(B

$B$=$l$O!"$^$5$7$/!"H`$,;v7o$K4,$-9~$^$l$?$HCN$C$?=V4V$KKM$NF,$K$h$.$C$?$3$H!"KM$NA[$$!"KM$N2y$7$5$G$b$"$j$^$9!#$=$3$GAaB.!"DE:j$5$s$HO"Mm$r$H$j!"$=$NJ8>O$NE>:\$r5v2D$7$F$$$?$@$-$^$7$?!#(B

$B$3$NJ8>O$K8l$i$l$F$$$k$h$&$K!"]!#%;%/%7%g%s!&%a%$%HF1;N$h$/8l$j9g$C$?!"$"$N%P%+;3$N

$B%K%e!<%9$r8+$F$b$&0l$DAI$C$?5-21$O!"H`$,="?&$r7h$a$?D>8e$K!"(B"D$B4[(B"$B$H$$$&7zJ*$N3X@8%i%&%s%8$G$9$l0c$C$?$H$-$K8r$o$7$?C;$$2qOC!#!V26$O6d9T$K9T$/$3$H$K$7$?$h!#$$$^0lHV@$$NCf$NF0$-$,8+$($k$N$O6bM;$N@$3&$@$+$i$M!#!WFHFC$NMn$ACe$-$r$b$C$?Dc$$@<$GH`$O$=$&$$$$$^$7$?!#Ev;~$O%P%V%k??$C@9$j$G!"F14|$NM}7O$NO"Cf$^$G$b$?$/$5$s6d9T$d>Z7t2q

$B$=$7$FEP$j$D$a$?@$3&KG0W%;%s%?!<$N:G>e3,!#@$3&$rMI$k$,$9Bg;v7o$KAx6x$7!"H`$O2?$r9M$($?$N$G$7$g$&$+!#H`$N$3$H$@$+$i!"2?$+$9$4$$$3$H$r9M$($F9TF0$K0\$7$F$$$?$N$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!#$=$l$rJ*8l$k>Z?M$b!">Z5r$b:#$O$J$/!"7k2LE*$KH`$NEXNO$O!"$"$NK=NO$NA0$G$OJs$o$l$J$+$C$?$H$7$F$b$M!#$-$C$H:#$b!"6u$N>e$G!"D4::G=NO$r6n;H$7$J$,$i!";~$K$O!"<+M3$K$J$C$?$=$N:2$G!"%Z%s%?%4%s$d%[%o%$%H%O%&%9!"(BCIA$B$N5!L);qNA$KL\$rDL$7!"$"$k$$$O%F%m%j%9%H$?$A$NHkL)$NDL?.$K<*$r$=$P$@$F!"$3$N@$3&$N9T$/Kv$K;W9M$r?J$a$F$$$k$N$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!#(B

$BJ8>O$NE>:\$r5v2D$7$F$$$?$@$$$?DE:j$5$s$K?<$/46

$B!V>.@n!"$b$&0lEY!"7/$H5DO@$,$7$?$$!W(B

$B!!:#G/!"KM$O!"%Y%k%j%s%U%#%k$rD0$/$?$a$NC;$$N99T$r$7$?!#$=$N$H$-!"N)$A4s$C$?K\20$G!"(B2$B:}K\$r;EF~$l$?!#(BArasse$B$N(BLEONARDO DA VINCI$B$H(BSCHIRMER$B$+$i=P$F$$$?(BLEONARDO DA VINCI Der Vogel Flug$B!#%a%b$r$H$j$J$,$i!"KM$O0l?M$N8eGZ$H?4$NCf$GBPOC$r7+$jJV$7$F$$$?!#>.@nBn!"7/$N$3$H$@!#(B

$B!!$?$H$($P!"%@%S%s%A$N%a%b$N0l$D$N3($K$D$$$F!#$3$N3(!":G=i$O!"2?$N$X$s$F$D$b$J$$Iw7J2h$K$_$($k!#$=$N$&$A!"1+$,=q$-9~$^$l$F$$$k$3$H$K5$$,$D$/!#$=$l$+$i9-$,$C$F1@!"1s$/$N3$$K$bL\$,$$$/!#=[4D!)$=$m$=$m?L$($,$/$k!#$3$N3(A4BN$,$0$k$0$k<~$j$O$8$a$k!#$=$&!"$=$3$K$OA41'Ch!J%3%9%b%9!K$NATBg$J=[4D$,IA$+$l$F$$$k$N$@!#$?$aB)$r$D$/!#$=$7$FKM$ONY$N8eGZ$K!"Sq$/!#!V$3$N46$8$o$+$k$@$m!W(B

$B!!>.@n$,!"?e8M0l9b$N@hGZ!"N)2VN4$N1F6A$N$b$H!"<+A32J3XA4BN$K$D$$$FAjEv$NCN<1$H8+<1$r$b$C$F$$$?$N$O!JKM$N$"$C$?Bg3X0lG/;~$K$7$F$9$G$K!K!"M-L>$J$3$H$@!#$=$N:"$N!J(B1984$BG/!)!K!"EEOCIt20$G$N%/%$%:M7$S$N$3$H$r3P$($F$$$k!#$?$^$?$^It20$K$"$C$?$=$NG/$N!V8=BeMQ8l$N4pACCN<1!W$r%M%?$K!"$@$l$+$,$=$3$K=P$F$$$?MQ8l$rJR$CC<$+$i%/%$%:D4$K.@n$H?t?M$N?7F~@8$,$$$?!#.$5$/$J$j!":G8e$O>.@n$NFHCE>l$@$C$?!#!VE7J8!W!VJ*M}!W!V2=3X!W4pAC2J3X$O$b$A$m$s!"!VDL?.!W!V>pJs!W!V%3%s%T%e!<%?!W$^$G!"$I$NJ,Ln$G$b(B100$B!sEz$($i$l$k!#.@n$OEz$(B3$1$k!#MM;R$r8+$F$$$?KM$O@e$r4,$$$?!#0E5-20$K$O$3$s$J7]Ev$O$G$-$J$$!#$3$$$D$O!"<+J,$NCf$KFH<+$N@$3&A|$r;}$C$F$$$F!"FbH/E*$J6=L#$G3Z$7$/JY6/$7$F$$$k$+$i!"$3$s$J$K$G$-$k$s$@$J$H!"$=$N$H$-;W$C$?!#(B

$B!!%@%S%s%A$rB4O@$N%F!<%^$K$7$?$N$O!"H`$K$OEvA3$N$3$H$@$C$?!#(B

$B!!KM$NCf$N!">.@n$O!"N@$N%=!<%7%c%k%k!<%`$N!"1x$$%=%U%!!<$N>e$K:B$C$F$$$k!#\$G!"$d$;$F$$$F!";~Be7`$N7u9k$r;W$o$;$kIw3J$"$k?MJ*$@$C$?!#H`$O$=$N@h@8$K.@n$H$O$h$/OC$7$?$,!"$=$NOC$N4VCfH`$N$B!!>.@n$r>]D'$9$kOC$r0l$D>R2p$7$?$$!#(B

$B!!$=$&!"9u4d%2!<%`$@!#(B

$B!!Bh0lCK;RN@$K!"$O$$$C$??7F~@8$O!"!V9u4d%2!<%`!W$H$$$&$N$K;22C$9$k!#(B

$B!!?7N@@8$O!"N@$K$O$$$C$?$H$-!"$^$o$j$N@hGZ$?$A$+$i!"$H$F$b$H$F$bBg;v$K$5$l$k!#3X?)$O!"$3$A$i$G$9$h!#$*IwO$$O$3$A$i!#7/$N$3$H$b$C$HCN$j$?$$$J!#$U!<$s!"7/$C$F$9$4$$$s$@$M!#$A$d$[$d$A$d$[$d!"?7N@@8$,$$$$5$J,$K$J$k$^$G!"AH?%E*$K$A$d$[$d$9$k!#(B

$B!!0l=54V$0$i$$!"$=$N>uBV$,B3$$$F!"?7N@@8$,!"N@@83h$X$N4uK>$KG3$(!"$0$C$9$j?29~$s$@Lk$K!"%2!<%`%9%?!<%H!#(B

$B!!H`$i$O!"FMA3!"LkCf(B12$B;~$4$m!"@D$6$a??7u$J4i$r$7$?!"@hGZ$N%k!<%`%a!<%H$K5/$3$5$l$k!#!V$9$^$s!"$A$g$C$H$*$-$F$/$l!#$&$k$5$$$d$D$,$+$($C$F$-$?$s$@!#5U$i$&$H2?$9$k$+$o$+$i$J$$$+$i!#$A$g$C$H$D$-$"$C$F!W!#I[CD$r$O$.$H$i$l!"$M$\$1$^$J$3$G5/$-$??7N@@8$O!"%Q%8%c%^$+$iIaCJCe$KCeBX$($k!#$=$l$+$iN@$N6a$/$NBY;3Aq$NDm$K@0Ns$5$;$l$l$k!#(BICU$B$N0E$$LZN)$NCf$K$8$C$H$7$F$$$k$N$O!"$=$l$G$J$/$F$bIT5$L#$J$3$H$@!#$^$7$F2?$N@bL@$b$J$/=8$a$i$l$??7N@@8$K$O!#2?$,5/$3$k$N$+62I]$K?L$(>e$,$C$F$7$^$&!#(B

$B!!4($5$K?L$($J$,$i$ND9$$D9$$;~4V$,$9$.$k!#LnHZ$J@<$H2.@n$N;~$O$?$7$+!{!{!{!{$,$3$NLr!K!#@hGZ$?$A$b$3$NCK$r62$l$F$$$k$N$+Cz=E$K@\$7$F$$$k!#$5$F$3$NCK!"?7F~@8$N4i$r$8$C$F$_$^$o$7$F$+$i!"1x$$%P%9$G$3$s$J$3$H$r8@$&!#!V$*$a$($i!":#$^$G$O$*5R$5$s$@$C$?$,$J!#:#F|$+$i$ON@@8$@!#!J$3$3$G4V!K!#$=$&$@$JN@@8$i$7$$$3$H!"$d$C$F$b$i$*$&$+$J!#:#$+$i=w;RN@$$$C$FL>;%!J%M!<%`%W%l!<%H!K$B!!LkCf$K=w;RN@!)!!$P$l$?$iB`3X!"0-$/$9$l$PCT4A07$$$GJ|9;$+$b!#?7N@@8$O!"$b$&%Q%K%C%/!#(B

$B!!8+$+$M$?N@D9$,!V9u4d$5$s!"$b$&$d$a$^$7$g$&$h!#$$$$$8$c$J$$$G$9$+!W$H$H$j$J$9!#!V!_!_!JN@D9$NL>A0!K$*$l$N$$$&$3$H$,J9$1$M$($N$+!W$H$$$&Ez$H$H$b$KN@D9$O2%$i$l$k!#0lH/$G$OD@$^$:!"N@D9$O!V$M$($d$a$^$7$g$&!W!#$b$&0lH/!#$3$l$G?7N@@8$N:G8e$NL#J}$bD@L[$9$k!#(B

$B!!62I]$K?L$(>e$,$C$?$^$^$N>uBV$G!"?7N@@8$?$A$O!"0l?M$:$D!"=w;RN@$KAw$j9~$^$l!"%M!<%`%W%l!<%H$rEp$^$5$l$k!#(B

$B!!=w;RN@$OBgA{$.!#?e$r$+$1$i$l$?$j!"=w;RN@$NN@@8$K$D$+$^$C$?$j!"?7N@@8$O$5$s$6$s$JL\$K$"$&!#(B

$B!!$[$&$[$&$N$F$$$G!"Bh0lCK;RN@$K!"5"$C$F$-$??7N@@8$O!"6~?+$H:#8e$N?4G[$GA40w@D$6$a$F$$$k!#%7%g%C%/$N$"$^$j<+<<$K5"$C$F2YJ*$r$^$H$a;O$a$?$B!!A40w$,5"$C$F$-$?$H$3$m$G!":F$S@0Ns!#$=$N$3$m$K$O!"A4N@@8!"=w;RN@$NN@@8$J$I4X78l!#?7N@@8$N6[D%$,:G9bEY$K9b$^$C$?$H$3$m$G!"9u4dLr$O8e$m$r$U$j$`$-!#!V8@$C$F$b$$$$$+$J!W!V$$$$$H$b!W!#(B

$B!!$3$N;~$N?7N@@8$NJQ2=$O!"$3$N%2!<%`$K:GBg$N8+J*!#$3$N0lO"$N=PMh;v$,;EAH$^$l$?%2!<%`$@$C$?$3$H$r!"$9$0$K$OGuBV$,B3$-!"$D$.$K0B?4$+$iNO$,H4$1$=$N>l$K:B$j$3$s$G$7$^$&!#(B

$B!VBh0lCK;RN@$X$h$&$3$=!W(B

$B!!KM$N$H$-$b!"KM$N;22C$7$?$B!!$?$@0l?M$NCK$rNc30$H$7$F!#(B

$B!!$=$NCK$O!":B$j9~$s$G$+$i$b$&0lEY$?$A$"$,$j!">eCe$N$&$A%]%1%C%H$+$i2?$d$i$H$j$@$7$F!"!V$3$lL5BL$@$C$?$s$G$9$M!W$H8@$C$?!#H`$N$H$j$@$7$?$N$O!">.7?$N%F!<%W%l%3!<%@!ZL@$9$k$?$a$N>Z5r$H$7$F!"$3$N%F!<%W$r=`Hw$7$F$$$?!#$5$C$-5/$3$5$l$?$H$-$K!"IT2:$J6u5$$r46$8$?$H$7$F$b!"2{$K%F!<%W%l%3!<%@!<$rG&$P$;$kCN7C$N$G$k$d$D$,$I$l$@$1$$$k$@$m$&!)(B

$B$3$N$9$4$$?7N@@8$,>.@nBn$@$C$?!#(B

$B65$($i$l$F$G$-$k$3$H$G$O$J$$!#5!E>$H$B!!CO5e5,LO$G!"Bg$-$J$H.@n$K$O5a$a$i$l$k;q$B!!B4N@0JMh!"7/$HO"Mm$r$B!!26C#$,!";~$N2O$NN.$l$NCf$KI:$&$B!!:#$O!"7/$H2q$($J$/$J$C$?$3$H$,!"$?$@$R$?$9$i!"Ha$7$$!#(B

2001.10.31


(8)

$B%?%J%H%/%i%7!c$H%F%m%j%:%`$NHkL)$N6&HH4X78(B

$B%F%m;v7o$H$=$NIpNOJsI|$K$D$$$F$"$l$3$l=q$-;O$a$F!"$^$b$J$/0l%v7n!#$D$$$D$$=q$/$3$H$O!"$I$&$7$F$b%"%a%j%+$N0G$NItJ,$K$J$C$F$7$^$&$N$G$9$,!"$$$D$b;W$&$N$O!"%"%a%j%+;TL1$N?4$,L~$5$l!">/$7$G$bAa$/@55$$KLa$C$F!"<+J,$?$A$N@/I\$,2?$rK\Ev$O$7$h$&$H$7$F$$$k$N$+$K5$$E$$$F$/$l$k!J>/$J$/$H$b5?$C$F$/$l$k!K$3$H!#$J$K$;$"$N9q$N;TL1$O!"$3$s$J;~@*$K$O;W$$$C$-$j1&$KBI$r$-$C$F$7$^$&!J@N$b%^%C%+!<%7%:%`$H$+$"$j$^$7$?$M!K$1$l$I!"$?$H$($P8xL18"1?F0$N5pBg$J$&$M$j$r@8$_=P$7r7o$KB:7I$7$A$c$&$H$3$m$G$9!#@/<#%7%9%F%`$G$bF|K\$,o$KLdBj$G$9$,!"$?$H$($P>pJs8x3+K!$H$+!"$"$k$$$OKM$N@lLg$K$R$-$D$1$F$$$($P!"!VO"K.;pLd0Q0w2qK!!W$N$h$&$J@lLg0Q0w2q$N8xJ?@-$dF)L@@-$r3NJ]$9$kK!N'$rDj$a!">/$J$/$H$b$=$l$r:,5r$K;TL1$,!"9T@/$d@lLg2H=8CD$rAjl$GAh$&$3$H$b$G$-$k$h$&$K$J$C$F$$$k$N$O!"$d$O$j=EMW$J$3$H$G$9$+$i!J(B$BJF9q4D6-5,@)@/:v$K$*$1$k!V@lLgE*%$%s%W%C%H!W$N$"$jJ}(B$B;2>H!K!#$H$O$$$(!"%F%m%j%9%H$N$d$j8}$O$"$^$j$KE0Dl$7$F$$$F!"%"%a%j%+;TL1$N?4$,L~$5$l$k2K$bM?$($:!"

$B0JA0$K$b=q$-$^$7$?(B$B$,!"%F%m$NK\Ev$N62$m$7$5$O!"@8L?$N4m81$H$$$&62I]$r!"$7$+$b!"$$$D$I$3$GC/$,;v7o$K4,$-9~$^$l$k$+$b$o$+$i$J$$$H$$$&7A$G?6$j$^$/$3$H$K$h$C$F!"$b$C$HK\Ev$K62$l$k$Y$-$3$H$KBP$9$k463P$r4JC1$KKcac$5$;$F$7$^$&$3$H$@$H;W$$$^$9!#$=$&$d$C$F!"DL>o$J$iF/$-$&$k%$%^%8%M!<%7%g%s$r0`=L!&9ED>2=$5$;!"I,$:$7$bK\Ev$K;TL1$N$?$a$r9M$($F$$$k$o$1$G$O$J$$0Y@/$N9q!9$N;XF3$B9=B$E*(B$B$K!V(B$B6&HH4X78(B$B!W$K$"$j!"3F!9$NK=NO$NH/F0$r!"$=$l$KBP$9$kL1=0$NH?F0$rMxMQ$7$J$,$i@5Ev2=$7!"6/2=$7$"$&$H$$$&$+$?$A$K$J$C$F$$$k$H$$$($^$9!#$=$3$G:G$b5>@7$K$5$l$F$$$k$N$O!"K\Mh!"%"%a%j%+J82=$,$b$C$H$bBg;v$K$7$F$-$?$O$:$NB?MM$J0U8+$N8rN.$r2?$h$j$bBg;v$K$9$kL1

$B%F%m$r$a$0$k$3$N!V6&HH4X78!W$K$D$$$F$O!"$I$3$+$N(Bweb page$B$GFI$s$@J8>O$G!"C/$+$,!"$4$j$4$j$N%$%9%i%`86M}o$K@>2$9gM}]$H$N$"$$$@$K$O$"$k$H$$$&$h$&$J$3$H$r$$$C$F$^$7$?!#!J$A$g$C$H$$$^$O%=!<%9$,ITL@$G$9$,!"$=$N$&$A8+$D$1$^$9!#!K$7$+$7!"$b$C$HD>Y#$+$D:,K\E*$J8+2r$H$7$F$O!"(B$B%]%j%m%4%9!&E/3X%/%m%K%/%k(B$B$N(B$B!V(B911$B%F%m;v7oFC=8!W(B$B$KK]Lu$N$"$k!"%8%g%k%8%)!&%"%,%s%Y%s$N!V(B$BHkL)$N6&HH4X78(B----$B0BA4J]>c$H%F%m%j%:%`$K$D$$$F(B$B!W$,6=L#?<$$$G$9!#%_%7%'%k!&%U!<%3!<$N%3%l!<%8%e!&%I!&%U%i%s%99V5A!X0BA4J]>c!"NNEZ!"?M8}!Y$K4p$E$$$F!"%F%m$H0BA4J]>c$K$D$$$F9M;!$7$F$$$k$b$N!#O@E@$r=&$C$F$*$-$^$7$g$&!#(B

$BBh0l$K!"%"%,%s%Y%s$K$h$l$P%U!<%3!<$O!"(B1978$BG/$N%3%l!<%8%e!&%I!&%U%i%s%9$N9V5A$G!"=EG@$B0BA4J]>c$,E}<#$NF;6q$H$7$F$O!"K!N'$H5,N'$KBPN)$9$k$b$N$H$7$FDs<($5$l$F$$$?(B$B!W$3$H$r<($7!"$$$/$D$+K!<#E*$J5,N'8"NO$H0BA4J]>c$N8"NO$H$NBPHf$r5s$2$?$&$($G!"!V0BA4J]>c$NA&6H!"8D?M$N%$%K%7%"%F%#%V$,!"$"$kDxEY$^$G$O<+M3$K$J$C$F$$$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#$=$N$?$a$K0BA4J]>c$H$$$&9M$(J}$,H/E8$9$k$H$H$b$K!"%j%Y%i%j%:%`$NM}G0$,M}2r$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$C$F$$$C$?!W$3$H$r<($7$F$$$k$=$&$G$9!#(B

$B$H$3$m$,!"8=Be$N$o$l$o$l$Nc$N;WA[$,6KC<$K$^$G!"$=$7$F$b$C$H$b4m81$J$H$3$m$^$GH/E8$7$?>u67$KD>LL$7$F$$$k!W$H%"%,%s%Y%s$O;XE&$7$^$9!#!V@/<#$,u67$K$*$$$F!"0BA4@-$rJ]>c$9$k$3$H$,!"9q$N9TF0$N4pK\E*$J86B'!W$H$J$C$F$7$^$C$F$$$k$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#$=$7$F!"$=$N$h$&$K0BA4J]>c$K$h$C$F$7$+@5E}@-$rJ]>Z$G$-$:!"9q$N2]Bj$,0BA4J]>c$7$+$J$$9q2H$O!"!V$D$M$K%F%m%j%9%H$+$i$ND)H/$r$&$1$F!"$_$:$+$i%F%m%j%:%`E*$J9q2H$K$J$k4m81$,$"$k!W$H$7!"B3$1$F%"%,%s%Y%s$O$3$&=q$$$F$$$^$9!JJ8Cf6/D4I.

$BBhFs-73$,@_N)$7$?HkL)7Y;!AH?%(B(OAS)$B$G!"$3$N>-73$O0&9qEg$K$*$1$k%2%j%i3hF0$K$?$$$9$kM#0l$NBP:v$O!"%F%m$@$H3N?.$7$F$$$?$3$H$r;W$$=P$=$&!#==H,@$5*$N9q2H3X!J%]%j%D%!%$3X!K$NM}O@2H$?$A$,C<:$7$F$7$^$&62$l$,$"$k$N$G$"$k!#$=$7$F:G8e$K$O!"(B$B0BA4J]>c$H%F%m%j%:%`$,(B$BC10l$N;`$N%7%9%F%`(B$B$r:n$j=P$7!"$3$N%7%9%F%`$N$&$A$G$?$,$$$KAj$B!#(B

$B$3$l$K$h$C$F!"9q2H$H%F%m%j%:%`$H$$$&K\Mh$OBPN)$9$k$O$:$N$b$N$,!"$3$C$=$j$H$B!#$=$l$@$1$G$O$J$$!#0BA4J]>c$r5a$a$k$"$^$j@$3&E*$JFb@o$X$HFMF~$7!"$9$Y$F$N?M!9$,;TL1$H$7$F6&B8$9$k$3$H$,IT2DG=$H$J$k$*$=$l$,$"$k$N$G$"$k!#u67$K$*$$$F$O!"0BA4J]>c$O%0%m!<%P%j%$B%0%m!<%P%j%

$B$3$l$K2C$($F$5$i$K%"%,%s%Y%s$O!"!V0BA4J]>c$G$O$D$M$K!J%7%e%_%C%H$N8l$C$?!KNc30>u67$K0M5r$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!W$?$a$K!"0BA4J]>cAc$OL1N)$G$-$J$$!W$H$$$&4m81@-$b;XE&$7$F$$$^$9!#!V%7%e%_%C%H$N8l$C$?Nc30>u67!W$H$O2?$J$N$+!"2IJ9$K$7$FCN$j$^$;$s$,!"MW$O!":#2s$N(B9.11$B%F%m;v7o$d0z$-B3$/C:aT6]%F%m$N$h$&$K:9$7Gw$C$?@8L?$N4m5!$KD>LL$7$F$$$k>u67$G$O!"8=

$B$@$+$i9q$N@/<#$NCf?4E*$J9M$(J}$H$J$C$F$$$k0BA4J]>c$N35G0$r:n$jD>$9$3$H$,!"$J$K$h$j$b6[5^$J2]Bj$H$J$C$F$-$?!#%h!<%m%C%Q$H%"%a%j%+$N@/<#2H$?$A$O!"0BA4J]>c$N%$%a!<%8$rCO5eE*$J5,LO$GL5HcH=E*$K:NMQ$9$k$H!":RLqE*$J5"7k$,K,$l$k2DG=@-$,$"$k$3$H$r9M$($k$Y$-$@!#!JCfN,!K(B$BL5Ca=x$HGKLGE*$J:RLq$r@)8f$9$k$@$1$G$J$/!"$=$NK,$l$rKI$0$?$a$KNO$r9g$o$;$k$Y$-$H$-$,$d$C$F$-$?$N$G$"$k(B$B!#(B

$B8=:_!"%(%3%m%8!$BL1r7o$,H/@8$9$k$N$rKI$0$3$H$G$"$k(B$B!#A~0-$d%F%m$dGK2u$,$9$G$K@8$^$l$F$+$i!"$3$l$r$I$&$K$+@)8f$9$k$N$,@/<#$N2]Bj$@$H9M$($F$O$J$i$J$$$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$=$&$@$H$9$l$P!"!V4m5!$,:9$7Gw$C$F$$$k:#!"%F%m$N860x$,2?$J$N$+$J$I5DO@$7$F$$$k2K$O$J$$!#$=$s$J$N$OHs8=e$N$"$A$3$A$N7G<(HD$G$b8+c$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$N$OEvA3$H$7$F$b!"$=$l$H$H$b$K%F%m$N@8$^$l$k:,K\E*>r7o$KL\$r8~$1!"5DO@$9$k<+M3$H6u4V$r3NJ]$73HBg$7$F$$$+$J$1$l$P!"%F%m%j%:%`$r$J$/$9$J$s$F7h$7$F$G$-$J$$$G$7$g$&!#C1$K%F%mAH?%$N;q6b8;$rCG$D$@$1$G$O$J$/!"%F%m%j%:%`$X$N>WF0$N8;$r@d$?$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#%F%m$H$=$N0BA4J]>cE*$J@)8f$,H4$-:9$7$J$i$J$$9=B$E*6&HH4X78$K$"$j!"!VC10l$N;`$N%7%9%F%`!W!=!=(B$B%?%J%H%/%i%7!<(B$B!=!=$r7A@.$7!"$=$N7k2L!"$=$&$7$?BN@)$K$^$9$^$9;TL1$r$,$s$8$,$i$a$K$9$k$h$&$J@/I\$d%a%G%#%"$N8@@b$,;YG[E*$J>u67$G$O!"$J$*$5$i$G$9!#$3$N%?%J%H%/%i%7!<$N;u$7$D$E$1$k0Y@/.@t7/!K$OJL$H$7$F!=!=$^$?!"%F%m%j%9%H$K$h$C$FIT9,$K$b$=$NCf$KEj$29~$^$l$F$7$^$C$?!J$=$N0UL#$G$NHo32l$K$$$k$o$l$o$l$,$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$:G$bBg;v$J$3$H$O!"6&HHE*$JK=NO$N:F@8;:AuCV$G$"$k%?%J%H%/%i%7!<$K93$7$F!";W9M$N<+M3$r3NJ]$7!"$G$-$k$@$1B?$/$N?M!9$HJ,$+$A9g$&$3$H$G$7$g$&!#%F%m%j%9%H$N967b$+$i@8L?$N0BA4$r8n$m$&$H$9$k$"$^$j!";W9M$K$^$G80$r$+$1$A$c$$$1$J$$!#!J$D$$$G$K$$$($P!"<+J,$N$J$+$N!V(B$BFb$J$k%F%m%j%:%`(B$B!W$K$b==J,7Y2|$7$J$$$H$$$1$J$$!#JsF;$,@5$7$$$H$9$l$P!"$$$^B?$/$N%"%a%j%+;TL1$,!VL14V?M$NHo32$b$d$`$J$7!W$H$$$&D4;R$G!"5;=QE*$K8+$F3Ne$,$C$F$/$k$"$kp$H$$$&$b$N$b!"$d$O$jFb$J$k%F%m%j%:%`$G$7$g$&!#@5D>8@$C$F!"KM<+?H$NCf$K$b!"%F%m%j%9%H$NM}6~$r(B$BM}2r$9$k(B$B$@$1$G$J$/!"$D$$$D$$!J;Y;}$O$7$J$/$F$b!K(B$B5q@d$7$-$l$J$$(B$B<+J,$,$$$?$j$7$^$9!#(BLove & Peace$B$8$c$J$$$J!"$C$F;W$$$^$9!#$A$J$_$K!VM}2r$9$k!W$3$H$H!V;Y;}$9$k$3$H!W$OA4A30c$&$3$H$G$9$,!"@$$NCf!"N>

$B$+$D$F%O%s%J!&%"%l%s%H$O!"%J%A%9!&%I%$%D$d%9%?!<%j%K%:%`!&%=O"$NA4BN$B9T0Y$9$k(B(act)$BBe$o$j$K!";W9M$r7g$$$?!=!=!V;W9M7gG!!J(Bthoughtlessness$B!K!W!=!=B8:_$H$7$F!"$"$?$+$bA4BN$G0l8D$N@8L?BN$N$h$&$K=89gE*!&@F0lE*$K(B$B9TF0$9$k(B(behave)$BB8:_$K$J$C$F$$$C$?$+$rIA$$$F$$$^$7$?!#%"%l%s%H$O!"A4BNC<:$7$F$7$^$C$?;~Be$N%F%m%k!=!=$K$h$C$F!"$?$d$9$/$=$&$$$&>uBV$K4Y$k$h$&$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$F$*$j!"$^$5$K!V1J5W$K5n$i$L@x:_E*$J4m81!W$H$7$F$NA4BN

$B%"%l%s%H$O$^$?!"A4BNe$N1?F0K!B'$H$7$F4SE0$5$l$F$$$/!VO@M}@-$N@l@)!W$K$"$k$HF6;!$7!"$?$H$($P

$B!VFbMF$,$$$+$K9SEbL57N$G$"$m$&$H!"$=$NZ$5$l!"$=$N@5$7$5$r>ZL@$7F@$k$N$OIT3NDj$NL$Mh$N$_$@$H$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$k$H!"EvA3$K$=$N%W%m%Q%,%s%@$O$-$o$a$F6/NO$JNO$rH/4x$9$k!#!W!J!XA4BN

$B$=$7$F!"$3$N$h$&$J%$%G%*%m%.!l86M}$NL5@)Ls$J3HBg!W$H$7$F$N%0%m!<%P%j%ZK!E*O@M}$rMQ$$$k$3$H$K$h$C$F!"L7=b$9$k;v2=$5$l$F$7$^$&$N$K$T$C$?$j$"$F$O$^$C$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B$^$!!"$3$N$h$&$J%0%m%P!<%j%$B%]%j%m%4%9!&E/3X%/%m%K%/%k(B$B$N(B$B!V(B911$B%F%m;v7oFC=8!W(B$B$K$"$k(B$B!V7zJ*$h$j$b$O$k$+$KH~$7$$0d@W!W(B$B$+$i$N0zMQ$G$9!#(B

$B%"%a%j%+$O967b$N@:L)$5$K62I]$r3P$($?!#$3$l$,%"%a%j%+$N$h$&$Je$,$j!"2=G?$7$F$7$^$&!#(B

$B$J$K$O$H$b$"$l!":#5/$-$F$$$k$3$H$O!"%*%5%^!&%S%s%i%G%#%s$,>'$($k!V%$%9%i%`@$3&BP%"%a%j%+!&@>B&@$3&$NF.Ah!W$G$b%V%C%7%e$,$$$&!V%F%m%j%9%HBP<+M3@$3&$NF.Ah!W$G$b$J$/!"N>/$7$G$bHsK=NOE*$JJ}8~$K;W9M$H9TF0$r$9$9$a$k$3$H$7$+$J$$$N$O4V0c$$$J$$$G$7$g$&!#%*%5%^$,$"$*$j!"%V%C%7%e$,IpNO9T;H$G8e2!$7$9$k%$%9%i%`BP@>B&$N9=?^$,8=$,$"$j$&$k$H$7$?$i!"%$%9%i%`@$3&$+$iBg$-$JHsK=NO1?F0$,M/$->e$,$j!"$?$H$($P$+$D$F$N%,%s%8!<$d%^%k%F%#%s!&%k!<%5!l$7$F!"%F%m%j%:%`$KBP$9$k;TL1!&L1=0$N46>pE*6&LD$rCG$A@Z$j!"56$j$N%R!<%m!$N@$3&$N?M!9$HO"BS$7$F$$$/$H$$$&$N$,%Y%9%H$J$N$G$7$g$&$,!"$=$l$O$A$g$C$HL5@UG$$JL4A[$J$N$+$J!#8=

$B$A$J$_$K:rF|$O!"5~ET$G9T$o$l$?%T!<%9%&%)!<%/$K!"0&8$%O%s%J$H$H$b$K2HB2$G;22C$7$F$-$^$7$?$,!":G=i$K;0>r$N2O86$G%9%T!<%A$,$"$j!"$=$N$J$+$G%K%e!<%h!<%/$GJk$i$7$F$$$?:_F|%"%a%j%+?M$NJ}$,!"!V$b$7$b!"5.J}$N0&$9$k?M$,$=$N;~;`$s$G$$$?$i!"<+J,$N0&$9$k39$,GK2u$5$l$?$i!"$I$&$7$^$9$+(B?$B!W$HLd$$!"!V$=$l$G$b$J$*$3$N%T!<%9%&%)!<%/$K;22C$9$k$H$$$&5$;}$A$r2r$C$FM_$7$$!W$H8l$C$F$$$^$7$?!#$=$&$$$&>.$5$J8D?M$N!"<+$iHa$7$_$d6l$7$_$r>h$j1[$($F;W9M$N<+M3$r2sI|$9$k!J$"$k$$$O2~$a$F3MF@$9$k!K9T0Y!=!=$=$l$O!"$=$&$G$-$J$$?M$O%@%a$@$H$$$&$3$H$G$O$J$$!"$H$$$&0UL#$G!"0l$D0l$D$,!V4q@W!W$H$7$F$=$N?M$K$b$?$i$5$l$?$b$N$@$H$$$($k$G$7$g$&!=!=$3$=$,8=$rBw$7$?$N$b!"$=$&$7$?H>$P28C~$H$7$FK,$l$k4q@W!"<+M3$J!V;O$^$j!W$H$7$F$N8D?M$N!V9T0Y(B(action)$B!W$N2DG=@-$G$"$j$^$7$?!#(B

$B!V?M4V$,3hF0$9$kG=NO$r;}$D$H$$$&;vr7o!Y(B289$BJG!K(B

2001.10.22


(7)

$B%V%C%7%e@/8"$O5f6K$N2P;v>lE%K@!)(B

$BL$$@%S%s%i%G%#%s;a$i$N5o=j$b$D$+$a$L$^$^!"B??t$NL14V?M5>@7

$B$=$N%K%e!<%9$O!"%"%a%j%+$N(BNGO$B!"(BFOOD FIRST$B$N%G%#%l%/%?!$K$"$d$+$C$F!V%H!<%^%9AaF;K!0F(B(Thomas Fast Track Bill)$B!W$H8F$P$l$k$b$N$G!"<+M3KG0W$K4X$9$k8r>D$K$D$$$F!"4D6-J]8n$dO+F/J$$$F!"BgE}NN$N<+M3:[NL$K0lG$$7$F$7$^$*$&$H$$$&!"$^$5$K%0%m!<%P%j%cJI$@!W$H$$$C$FGS=|$9$k$H$$$&IUBS>r9`$D$-$@$=$&$G$9!#!K(B

$B$3$l$@$1$G$b==J,$H$s$G$b$J$$K!0F$J$N$G$9$,!"$J$s$H$3$l!"!V%F%mBP:v!W$N0l4D$H$7$F!":#2s$N;v7o$KJ8;zDL$jJX>h$7$F=P$5$l$?$b$N$J$N$@$=$&$G$9!#$^$5$K5f6K$N2P;v>lE%K@!*!*(B

$B$7$?$?$+$H$$$($P$7$?$?$+$G$9$,!"$"$^$j$K$R$I$$!#$=$NO)@~$G%0%m!<%P%j%$N%"%i%V=t9q$K$K$i$_$b8z$+$;$l$P!"%V%C%7%e(B&$B%A%'%$%K!<$NBg9%$-$J@PL}!&%(%M%k%.!<6H3&$b%&%O%&%O$G$$$$$N$+$b$7$l$^$;$s$,!"$"$^$j$K%(%2%D$J$$$G$9!"%V%C%7%e@/8"!#(B

$B$3$l$8$c$"!"%I%5%/%5J6$l$K!"$+$D$F$N%9%Q%$KI;_K!$N0lIt!JKI1R5!L)$NO31L$O!"L14V?M$^$G4^$a$Fr9`!K$,F~$C$?<+1RBbK!2~@50F$H0l=o$K=05D1!DL2a$7$A$c$C$?!V<+1RBbGI8/K!!W!JCG$8$F!V%F%mBP:v!WK!$H$7$F$N0UL#$O$J$$$?$@$NGI8/K!!K$,2D0&$/8+$($A$c$$$^$9!#!J$b$A$m$s!"$3$l$O$3$l$G==J,?<9o$J$N$@$1$I!#!K(B

$B$H$$$&$o$1$G!"$"$^$j$K%(%2%D$J$$$N$G!"(BFOOD FIRST$B$N%5%$%H$K$"$k(BAnuradha Mittal$B$5$s$N5-;v$rLu$7$A$c$$$^$7$?!#!J86J8$O(BCountering Terrorism with Trade? (October 9, 2001)$B!K(B

$B<+M3KG0W$G%F%m%j%:%`$HBP7h!)(B

9$B7n(B11$BF|$KL5$B$"$N62$k$Y$-;v7o$K$h$C$F!"%V%C%7%e$N8:@G$d!"O"K.M=;;M>>j6b$N;H$$ES!"A}Bg$9$kKG0W@V;z!"45OE5!"$=$NB>=EMW$J$B9qL1$N4X?4$,:#2s$NHa7`$K=8Cf$7$F$$$k0lJ}$G!"5D2q$KBP$7$F%V%C%7%e@/8"$O!"9q:]%F%m%j%:%`$H$NF.$$$N0l=u$H$7$F!"KG0W6(Dj$K$D$$$F8r>D$9$kAaF;E*$J<+M3:[NL8"!=!=?7$?$K!VKG0WB%?J:[NL8"(B(Trade Promotion Authority)$B!W$HL>$E$1$i$l$?!=!=$rBgE}NN$KM?$($k$h$&@bF@$7;O$a$F$$$k!#9g=09qKG0WC4Ev$N%m%P!<%H!&%>!<%j%C%/(B(Robert Zoelick)$B2<1!5D0w$O!"KG0WB%?J:[NL8"$O!"%F%m%j%9%H$N6<0R$+$i<+M3KG0W$r8n$k$3$H$b4^$a$F!"9g=09q$,@$3&$KIi$C$F$$$k$=$N@UG$$rJ|4~$9$k$3$H$O$J$$$H$$$&Bg$-$J%7%0%J%k$NLr3d$r2L$?$9$@$m$&$H$BHa7`$O!"%"%a%j%+?M$N?4$Hl$G!"?I$$>u67$KD>LL$7$D$D$"$k!#(BNAFTA($BKLJF<+M3KG0W6(Dj(B)$B$N$*$+$2$G<:6H$K?&$r8+$D$1$i$l$?$H$7$F$b!"0JA0$N<73d0J2<$N<}F~$7$+F@$i$l$J$$!#(B

$BKG0W6(Dj$O!"0B$$O+F/NO$H@8;:%3%9%H$K$h$C$FMx1W$rF@$h$&$H$9$k;qK\2H$?$A$K$H$C$F$3$N>e$J$$@.8y$G$"$C$?!#$[$H$s$I$N%"%a%j%+?M$O@83h$N$?$a$KF/$$$F$$$k$,!"Ej;q$GJk$i$7$rN)$F$F$$$k$o$1$G$O$J$$!#(BNAFTA$B$@$1$K$h$C$F!"(B766,000$B?MJ,$N8[MQ$,(B1994$BG/$+$i(B2000$BG/$N$"$$$@$K<:$o$l$?!#KG0W<+M32=$N7k2L$G$"$k%"%a%j%+$NKG0W@V;z$NA}Bg$K$h$C$F!"(B1992$BG/$+$i(B1999$BG/$N$"$$$@$K(B320$BK|?M$N8[MQ$,<:$o$l$F$$$k!#;qK\0\F0$KBP$9$k@)8B$,7gG!$7$F$$$k$3$H$O!"O+F/DNO$,9$B7n(B11$BF|$N967b$O!"%F%m$KKG0W$GBP93$9$k$H$$$&Bg5AL>J,$G!"%V%C%7%e@/8"$,J|0o$J4k6H$NlEM_$5$rNO$E$1@5Ev2=$9$k@d9%$N5!2q$KMxMQ$5$l$k$Y$-$G$O$J$$!#F1@/8"$,$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$N$O!"8[MQ$rAO=P$7!"<:6HJd=~$rM?$(!"$9$Y$F$N?M!9$N@83h$,0];}$5$l$k$h$&$J7P:Q$rC[$->e$2$k$N$KEXNO$9$k$3$H$@!#$o$l$o$l$KI,MW$J$N$O!";TL1$H8=:_4m5!$KIN$7$F$$$k;:6H$K>GE@$r$"$F$k$3$H$G$"$C$F!"9q2HE*Ha7`$r?)$$J*$K$7$F!"ITOBJ,Nv$r>7$/$h$&$J4k6H%"%8%'%s%@$r?d$7?J$a$k$3$H$G$O$J$$$N$@!#0l$D$N9q2H$H$7$F$o$l$o$l$O!"$5$i$J$kGK2u$r@8$_$@$9Be$o$j$K!"@$3&Cf$NJ?OB$H@55A$rK\Ev$KB%?J$G$-$k$h$&$J%F%m%j%:%`$X$NBP1~$r9=A[$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$N$G$"$k!#(B

2001.10.19


$B!J(B6$B!K(B

$B?92,@5Gn$5$s$N(B$BBPJF%F%m;v7oJsF;$rAjBP2=$9$k$?$a$K(B$B$G8+$D$1$?%3%s%5!<%H$G$N(B$B2N$B!'(B

"Last night, we had a minute of prayer for everybody who died on Tuesday," said the singer, who had traded her Scottish kilt for a skirt made from an American flag for her first costume of the evening. "Tonight I'd like to say a prayer for peace." The crowd obliged her request for a moment of silence, but fans soon began chanting "U-S-A" as many waved American flags frantically. Relenting, Madonna said, "OK, USA. But start looking at the whole world. I said it last night and I'll say it again: If you want to change the world, change yourself."

$B@V;zItJ,$r%^%I%s%J$C$]$/Lu$7$F$_$k$H!"$3$s$J46$8$+$J!#(B

$B!V$o$+$C$?$o!"9g=09q!#$@$1$I@$3&A4BN$r8+$F$_$h$&$8$c$J$$!):rF|$NLk$b8@$C$?$1$I!"$b$&0lEY8@$&$o$M!#$b$7$b@$3&$rJQ$($?$$$N$J$i!"$"$J$?$?$A<+?H$rJQ$($J$5$$!#!W(B

2001.10.13


$B!J(B5$B!K(B

$B$D$$$K967b3+;O!*!*(B
$B@oAh$O%"%a%j%+$N8x6&;v6H!)(B

$B$H$&$H$&!VJsI|!W967b$,;O$^$C$F$7$^$$$^$7$?!#:#Lk$G$b$&(B3$BF|L\!#JsF;$K$h$k$H6uGz$O$"$H?tF|$/$i$$$G!"$"$H$OCO>e@o$J$I$K0\$k$i$7$$!&!&!&(B

$B$$$^$N$H$3$mJ9$3$($F$/$k%K%e!<%9$G$O!"%"%U%,%s$G$NL14V?M$N;`$,;&$5$l$?$H$N$3$H!#OQ4_@oAh$N$H$-$b%3%=%\J6Ah$N$H$-$b$=$&$G$7$?$,!"!V%T%s%]%$%s%H$G73;v;\@_$rA@$C$F$k$+$iBg>fIW!W$H$$$&$N$O%W%m%Q%,%s%@$G!"=jA'!"%_%5%$%k$NL?CfN($OL$$@$K$=$&9b$/$J$$$H$$$&$3$H$J$N$G$7$g$&!#!J8m:9(B10$B%a!<%H%kA08e$H$+8x<0H/I=$5$l$F$k$1$I!"

$B$H$3$m$G!"0l:rF|2q$C$?M'?M$+$iLLGr$$$3$H$rJ9$-$^$7$?!#!V(B$B%"%a%j%+7P:Q$K$H$C$F$N@oAh$O!"F|K\$K$H$C$F$N8x6&EZLZ;v6H$HF1$8$@(B$B!W$H$$$&OC$G$9!#(B

$BH`$O$$$^!"(B93$BG/$KCf;_$K$J$C$?%"%a%j%+$N(BSSC($BD6EEF3D6Bg7?N3;R2CB.4o(B)$B7z@_7W2h(B$B$K$D$$$F!"$=$N@/<#7P:QE*GX7J$NJ,@O$b4^$a$?Gn;NO@J8$r<9I.Cf$J$s$G$9$,!"$=$N2aDx$G!"Ev;~$NJF9q%(%M%k%.!<>J<~JU$N?ML.$H$=$N%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I$rD4$Y$F$?$i!"$I$C$A$c$j$H73;v;:6H4X78

$B$=$7$F!"$3$l$rD4$Y$k$J$+$G!"F|JF$NO+F/?M8}$N6HCHq$7!"73;v;:6H$r=a$5$J$$$H$$$1$J$$$i$7$$$N$G$9!#(B

$B$b$H$b$H:#2s$N@oAh$G$b!"$$$o$f$k!V73;:J#9gBN(B(Militaly-Industry Complex)$B!W$NMx32$,Mm$s$G$$$k$N$@$m$&$H$OBgJ}?dB,$7$F$^$7$?$,!"$3$NJ#9gBN$N9-$,$j$,$=$l$[$I%"%a%j%+7P:Q$N$J$+$GBg$-$J0LCV$r@j$a$F$$$k$H$O;W$$$^$;$s$G$7$?!#$3$N7o$K4X$9$kM'?M$N8&5f$O$^$@=i4|CJ3,$J$N$G!"$O$C$-$j$H$7$?$3$H$O$^$@8@$($J$$$h$&$G$9$,!"$$$:$l6=L#?<$$7k2L$,=P$F$/$k$3$H$G$7$g$&!#!J$A$J$_$KH`$O!"(BSSC$B7W2hCf;_$NGX7JD4::$G!"@h7n8eH>$K%"%a%j%+$N%(%M%k%.!<>J$H9qKIAm>J!=!=%Z%s%?%4%s!=!=$rK,Ld$9$kM=Dj$@$C$?$N$@$1$I!"D>A0$K$"$N;v7o$,5/$-$?$N$GCf;_$K$7$?$=$&$G$9!#!K(B

$B!V%"%a%j%+$N308r@/:v$O9qFb@/<#$N1dD9$G$"$k!W$H$$$&$N$O!"@N!"9q:]4X78O@$r$A$g$C$H$+$8$C$?:"$KFI$s$@OC$G$7$?$,!":#$b$=$l$OJQ$o$C$F$$$J$$$h$&$G$9!#F|K\$N8x6&;v6HLdBj$G!"0l$D0l$D$N9)L3E9$dEZ7z20$N$*$8$5$s$d$*7;$A$c$s$,0-$$$o$1$G$O$J$$$h$&$K!"%"%a%j%+$N73;:J#9gBN$N2<$K$V$i2<$,$C$F$$$k0l$D0l$D$ND.9)>l$d9)0w$N?M$K$3$l$H$$$C$?:a$O$J$$$N$@$m$&$1$I!"$I$A$i$b%7%9%F%`$N>e$K9T$1$P9T$/$[$I!"8"8BHO0O$,Bg$-$/$J$l$P$J$k$[$I!"$=$N%7%9%F%`$,@8$_=P$9=t0-$N@UG$$b$^$?Bg$-$$!=!=$H$/$K@/<#2H!=!=$N$O8@$&$^$G$b$"$j$^$;$s!#$1$l$I$b!"5U$K!"!V0-!W$O;:6H7P:Q9=B$A4BN$K:,?<$/3H;6E*$K9=B$2=$5$l$F$*$j!"0l$D0l$D$N:a$J$-9T0Y$N@Q$_=E$M$,%7%9%F%^%F%#%C%/$K0-$r@8;:$7$D$E$1$k9=B$$O!"8D?M$K@UG$$r5"$9$3$H$G$O:Q$^$J$$LdBj$G$"$j!"8=Be$B0-$NDDIe$5(B(vanality of evil)$B!W$H$$$&35G0$rDs0F$7$^$7$?!J(B$B!X%$%'%k%5%l%`$N%"%$%R%^%s!=0-$NDDIe$5$K$D$$$F$NJs9p!Y(B$B!K!#$=$l$O!"%f%@%d?MBg5T;&$H$$$&?MN`;K>e:GBg$H$b$$$($k5p0-!=!=@dBP0-!=!=$r9T$($k$N$O!"$$$C$?$$$I$l$[$I0-KbE*$JB8:_$J$N$+$H;W$C$F$$$?$i!"o$N6HL3$N?k9T$K$h$C$F!"6K$a$FC8!9$H9T$o$l$?$b$N$@$C$?$H$$$&;v$B;W9M7gG!(B(thoughtlessness)$B!W!=!=<+J,$N9T0Y$N0UL#$r9M$($J$$$3$H!=!=$@$C$?$o$1$G$9$,!"$=$l$O:#2s!"$"$k$$$OOQ4_@oAh$J$I2a5n$N$b$N$b4^$a$?%"%a%j%+$K$h$k@oAh9T0Y$K$D$$$F$b$$$($k$N$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!J$b$A$m$s%F%m%j%9%H$?$A$K$b$M!K!#%i%`%:%U%'%k%H9qKIAj$d!"%V%C%7%eBgE}NN$b!"@/<#2H$,$=$l$>$l;Y;}

$B$H$O$$$(!"$?$H$($P%"%s%=%K!$O$J$$$H$$$&$N$,!":G4|$K(B$B!X@:?@$N@83h!Y(B$B$G;W9M!"0U;W!"$=$7$FL$40$NH=CGNO$K$D$$$F;W:w$r$a$0$i$7$?%"%l%s%H$N@836$N7kO@$G$b$"$j$^$7$?!#(B

$B@N=q$$$?%"%l%s%H$K$D$$$F$N(B$B@[O@(B$B$+$i$N0zMQ$G$9(B:

"...the deeper the darkness is, the brighter the stars shine, and the more clearly one sees the depth of the darkness."

2001.10.9


$B!J(B4$B!K(B

$B:#F|!";u0e

$B!V$"$s$?!"$$$C$?$$$I$3$N9q$N%$%G%*%m!<%0!)!W$H$$$&$N$,>.@8$N:G=i$N46A[!#$$$C$?$$$3$N?M$N8@$&!VCa=x0];}!W$C$F2?$J$N$@$m$&!)3N$+$K!"L14V?M$rL5:9JL$K967bBP>]$H$7$?%F%m9T0Y<+BN$O!"L@$i$+$JHH:a!"$=$l$bD6W85i$NHH:a$G$"$k$N$O4V0c$$$J$/!"HH?M$rJa$^$(!"$=$&$7$?0oC&$KBP$9$kH3$rM?$(!"$5$i$J$kHH:a$N2j$rE&$`$3$H$OF;5AE*Ca=x$N0];}!&2sI|$N$?$a$@$H$$$&$N$O!"!JHH?M0J30$O!KC/$b$,GJ$N%l%Y%k$NLd$$$O$R$H$^$:CV$$$F$*$$$F!"$"$/$^$G

$B$1$I$M!r4z$r8f4z$K$OF|K\$N9q1W$KE,$&$N!)$J$s$F$3$H$b;W$C$?$j$b$7$^$9!JE,$&$H;W$C$F$F!"$-$C$HE,$C$F$7$^$&GZ$?$A!=!=0&9qLL$r$+$V$C$?Gd9qE[$H8F$s$G$b$$$$$+$b!=!=$b$$$k$s$G$7$g$&$1$I!K!#%?%j%P%s$NZ5r$b!V%"%a%j%+@/I\H/I=!W$H$$$&0J30$K2?$NN"IU$1$b$J$$>u67$@$H$$$&$N$K!"$$$D$N$^$K$d$i!V%$%i%/$bF$$D$Y$7!W$H$$$&%7%J%j%*$,DjCe$7$D$D$"$j$^$9$7!#$=$&$$$($P(B2$B=54V$/$i$$A0$ND+F|?7J9$N5-;v$@$C$?$1$I!"!V1Q73$,%$%i%/$r6uGz!W$H$$$&$N$,$"$j$^$7$?$,!"$3$l$C$FOQ4_@oAh0JMh$:$C$HB3$$$F$$$kJF1Q$N!V6uGzDj4|JX!W$J$s$G$9$h$M!#JL$K%U%;%$%sBgE}NN$rMJ8n$9$k$o$1$8$c$J$$$1$I!"$3$N(B10$BG/4V$N1QJF$N6uGz$d!"Nt2=%&%i%sCF$,860x$H5?$o$l$F$$$k7r9/Ho32(B($B!V(B$BNt2=%&%i%sCF$H7P:Q@):[!]OQ4_@oAh8e$N%$%i%/(B$B!W(B)$B!"7P:Q@):[$K$h$k?)NH$d0eLtIJ$NITB-$N$?$a$K%$%i%/$G$O(B150$BK|?M$,;`$s$G$$$k$H$$$&(BUNICEF$B$NE}7W$,$"$C$?$j$7$^$9!#$=$m$=$m!V2T$.8}!W$rF@$?$$73<{;:6H$+$i$NMW@A$J$I$b6/$$$N$+$bCN$l$^$;$s!#$$$:$l$K$;$h8=/$7$b@/<#E*$KCfN)E*$J8@MU$J$s$+$8$c$J$/$F!"$`$7$mCfN)@-$rAu$&$3$H<+BN$,;W$$$C$-$j%]%j%F%#%+%k$@$C$F$3$H$rL5;k$7$F$k$N$,!">e$N5-;v$NH/8@$G$"$k$o$1$G!"$=$N$X$s$,0lHV$3$N

$B$H$O$$$(!"H`$H$OA4A30c$&0UL#$G!"!VK=NO$,@8$`$5$i$J$kK=NO$HA~$7$_!W$H$$$&O":?!"%F%m$N@$3&E*IQH/2=$,;v$NK\oE*$G8+$($K$/$$K=NO@-!=!=$d!"JF1Q$NCfEl@/:v!J$H$/$K%P%l%9%A%JLdBj!K$N<::v$HL@$i$+$JJP8~$,!"2?$iH?>J$5$l$k$3$H$J$/!"$5$i$K3HBg6/2=$5$l$A$c$&$3$H$G$7$g$&!#8=/$J$/$H$b$"$NCO0h$K$*$$$F$O!"%F%m%j%9%H$NAH?%$r2uLG$5$;$k$N$KAa!9$K@.8y$7!"!JK\Ev$K:#2s$NHH?M$G$"$k$+$I$&$+$OJ$_$i$l2~$a$i$l$k$3$H$,$J$$$J$i$P!"J8;zDL$j$=$l$OBP>INEK!$G$7$+$J$/!"@$3&$OAj$bJQ$o$i$:$8$o$8$o$HIB$,?<$^$j!"%F%m%k$b$^$9$^$9IQH/$9$k$3$H$G$7$g$&!#C/$NL\$K$bL@$i$+$J5p0-$,!"F|>o2=$5$l9*L/$KL50U<12=$5$l$?$b$&0l$D$N!J$b$C$HBg$-$J!K??$C9u$N5p0-$r!"!VL59$$NA1NI!W!V@55A!W$H$$$&Au$$$N8w$GJ$$$1#$7$F$7$^$&$H$$$&$N$,!"$d$C$Q$j0lHV62$m$7$$!#(B

$B$$$:$l$K$;$h$3$N@h$O!"$3$N5p0-$NB8:_!"F|>o2=$7@$3&2=$7$F$$$k$,8N$KIT2D;k$NIT@55A$r$I$&M}2r2DG=$J$+$?$A$GL@$k$_$K=P$7!"BP93$7$F$$$/$+!"$=$N$?$a$N?M!9$N$D$J$,$j$r%0%m!<%P%k$KC[$$$F$$$/$+$H$$$&$N$,M}O@E*$K$bB&@$3&!"H?JFBP?FJF!J!a=>JF!K!"H?%0%m!<%P%j%

$B$D$$$G$K$$$($P%F%m%j%:%`$N62$m$7$5(B$B$N0l$D$O!"$b$C$HK\Ev$K62$l$k$Y$-$3$H$KBP$9$k463P$r4JC1$KKcac$5$;$F$7$^$&$3$H$N$h$&$J5$$,$7$^$9!#$?$H$($PKM$,=;$s$G$k5~ET$@$H!"$b$7$b%"%a%j%+$NJsI|!JJL$K!V@):[!W$G$b$$$$$1$I!K$KBP$9$kJsI|%F%m$GJ!0f$N86H/6d:B$,967b$5$l!"KLIw$G$b?a$$$?$i3N/$J$/$H$bF|K\$J$s$+$K=;$s$G$k?H$@$H!"MF0W$KK\Mh:G$b46$8$F$*$/$Y$-62I]!=!=%"%8%"$d%"%U%j%+!"CfEl$N0lIt$K9T$1$P!"$=$l$O@8L?$N4m5!$KD>7k$7$F$k$o$1$G$9$,!=!=$r$&$A>C$7$F$7$^$$$^$9$+$i!#$=$N$"$?$j!"?4;}$A$H$7$F$O!"$A$g$C$H%N!<%,!<%I@oK!!J%8%g!,$G$"$j$^$7$?!#(B

2001.10.5


$B!J(B3$B!K(B

$B%F%m$OCG8G$H$7$F5jCF$5$l!"K!$N2<$G:[$+$l$J$1$l$P$J$j$^$;$s!#(B

$B$I$s$J!VBg5A!W$,$"$C$?$K$;$h!"$"$N$h$&$JK=NO$KAJ$($?;~E@$GH`$i$OCWL?E*$K4V0c$C$F$$$k!#(B

$B$=$l$HF1;~$K!"$3$NK=NO$KBP$7$F%"%a%j%+@/I\$,=`Hw$7$F$$$kJsI|967b$b$^$?!"CG8G$H$7$F4V0c$C$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B$=$N7kKv$O!"%F%m%j%9%H$KBP$9$k%"%a%j%+$N>!Mx$J$s$+$G$O$J$/!"$3$l$^$G$N%"%a%j%+$K$h$k@oAh9T0Y$N7kKv$HF1MM$K!"D>@\$N967b$dJ*;q6!5kCG@d$K$h$k52$(!"FqL12=$K$h$k%"%U%,%s$NL1$N$5$i$J$k6l6-$HTn$7$$?t$N;`$r$b$?$i$7!"$R$$$F$O!"$5$i$J$kA~$7$_$H%F%m$N1~=7$r@8$_=P$9$3$H$K$7$+$J$i$J$$$N$G$9$+$i!#(B

$B$=$7$F$=$l$O!"JsI|$NAje$KK=NOE*$J!=!=(B$B54C\F;(B$B$K%"%a%j%+$dB>$N@h?J9q$,BD$A$F$7$^$&$,$f$($K4V0c$C$F$$$k$@$1$G$O$"$j$^$;$s!#!V(B$BL58B$N@55A(B$B!W$J$I$H$$$&>/G/L!2h$G$9$i:#$d;H$o$J$/$J$C$F$$$k$h$&$JDDIe$J$+$1@<$K$h$C$F!"(B$B<+J,$?$A<+?H$NIT@55A(B$B!=!=9q:]E*$J@/<#E*!&7P:QE*ITJ?Ey$r@8$_=P$70];}$73HBg$7$F$$$k@h?J9q$N7P:Q%7%9%F%`!"%Q%l%9%A%JLdBj$X$NL5@UG$$GJP$C$?@/I\$NBP1~$dLdBj$=$N$b$N$KL5CN$JB?$/$N;TL1$NB8:_!"OQ4_@oAh$J$IBg5A$NL>$N$b$H$NL14V?M$NBgNL;&Y$$H<+J,$?$A$N$I$99u$$@/<#E*!&7P:QE*Mx1W$NJ]8n!"$=$7$F$J$s$G$b$+$s$G$b$4$j2!$7$NK=NO$KAJ$($kLnHZ$5$HP~K}$5!=!=$rJ$$$1#$=$&$H$9$k$,$f$($K4V0c$C$F$b$$$k$N$G$9!#C<$+$i8+$l$P%"%a%j%+@/I\$O!"$^$k$G!V$o$l$o$l0J30$K$J$i$:E*$JB^>.O)$KH`$i$rDI$$9~$s$G$$$kMW0x$NBg$-$JItJ,$r!"%"%a%j%+$r$O$8$a$H$9$k@h?J9q$NIT@55A$,@j$a$F$$$k$N$OL@$i$+$G$9!#!J$"$($F$$$($P!"%F%m%j%9%H$,4V0c$C$F$$$k$N$O!"H`$i<+?H$,

$B$?$H$($F$$$($P!"M%Ey@8LL$7$?$$$8$a$C;R$,$$$8$a$i$l$C;R$K;I$5$i$l$?$N$,:#2s$N%F%m;v7o$G$"$j!";I$7$?$$$8$a$i$l$C;R$,!"HH$7$?:a$N$f$($K:[$+$l$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$N$HF1;~$K!"0lJ}E*$JHo32LL$rGm$,$7!"<+?H$N:a$NBg$-$5$HD>LL$5$;$J$1$l$P!"Ha7`$O7h$7$F=*$o$k$3$H$O$J$$$G$7$g$&!#!J$^$!!":#2s$N%1!<%9$G$O!":#$d!V$$$8$a$i$C;R!W$O@$3&5,LO$N%M%C%H%o!<%/$r;}$C$?$b$&0l$D$N!V$$$8$a$C;R=8CD!W$r:n$C$F!"AH?%E*$JJsI|$KBG$C$F=P$F$-$F$$$k!VHH:a

$B!VK=NO$G$O$J$/J?OBE*2r7h$r!W$H$$$&@<$KBP$7!"0lIt$NI!B)9S$$;wHs0&9q

$B$b$A$m$s:#2s$N%F%m;v7o$OCG$8$F5v$5$l$F$O$J$i$:!"@$3&Cf$NA\::5!4X$NAmNO$r$b$C$F!"HH?M$rJa$^$(!"$5$i$J$k%F%m$rL$A3$KKI$0$h$&$K$7$J$1$l$P$J$j$^$;$s!#$1$l$I$b$=$l$,!"%F%m$+$i;k$HO"F0$7$F$$$J$1$l$P!"H`$i%F%m%j%9%H$?$A$N9T0Y$O!=!=$3$&$$$&8@$$J}$r$9$k$H8m2r$r>7$-$=$&$G$9$,!=!=$"$^$j$KL50UL#$G$9!#$$$C$F$_$l$P:#2s$N;v7o$N5>@7@7$GL?$r<:$C$??M!9$d$=$N2HB2!&M'?M$,Ho32$l2C32/$J$/$H$bH`$,<+?H$N9T0Y$G<+$i$N?M@8$rGK2u$7$F$7$^$&$N$rKI$0$3$H$G$b$"$k$7!"$=$&$G$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$H;W$&$N$G$9!#$b$A$m$s8e/$J$/$H$b!K2DG=@-$KBP$9$k4uK>$,2j@8$($k$h$&$JC{$7!"$D$^$j@$3&$N:,K\E*$JIT@55A$KBP$9$k!VF.$$!W$,!"H`$i$rJa$^$(:[$/$3$H$HF1;~$K9T$o$l$D$D$"$k!">/$J$/$H$b$=$N0U;W$,$h$jB?$/$N?M!9$K6&M-$5$l$F$$$k$H$$$&;v

$B!V%F%m%j%9%H<+?H$r5_$&!W$@$J$s$F!"$J$s$@$+!"$D$$$D$$%F%m%j%9%H$K8*F~$l$7$?$h$&$J$3$H$r9M$($F$7$^$&$N$G$9$,!"/$J$/$H$b(B$B=89gE*$J!V$o$l$o$l!W(B$B$H$7$F$N$o$l$o$l$O$I$&$J$N$+!)%F%m%j%9%H$b4^$`5T$2$i$l$?9q!9$NL10l?M0l?M$KBP$7$F!"$H$F$D$b$J$$:a$rHH$7$F$O$$$J$$$@$m$&$+!)$^$7$F$dJsI|@oAh$J$I!"%F%m%j%9%H$NL5:9JL;&?M$HF1$8$G$"$k$@$1$G$J$/!"$=$b$=$b$3$l$^$G$bB?$/$N?M!9$KL5:9JL$KK=NO$rF/$$$F$-$?@h?J9q$N:a$N>eEI$j$G$7$+$J$$$N$G$O$J$$$+!)5o?4CO0-$/46$8$k$N$O!"$"$^$j$KO*9|$J%F%m%j%9%H$?$A$NK=NO$N$9$08~$3$&B&$K!"!V$o$l$o$l!W<+?H$,F|!92CC4$7$D$D$b5$$E$+$J$$$G$$$k!"$b$7$/$O5$$E$+$J$$$h$&$K$7$F$$$kJL$N=89gE*K=NO!"@$3&$N:,K\E*$JIT@55A$N9=B$$,H]1~$J$/$@$V$C$F8+$($F$7$^$&$+$i$KB>$J$j$^$;$s!#(B

$B$=$7$F!"$3$N@$3&$N:,K\E*IT@55A$N;v;k$HH?>J$,H<$o$l$F$$$J$1$l$P!"%F%m%j%:%`$HF.$$!"%F%m%j%9%H$?$A$rJa$^$(:[$/$3$H$b!"H`$i$KBP$9$kJsI|967b$K0[$r>'$(!VJ?OBE*2r7h$r!*!W$H6+$V$3$H$b!"$I$A$i$bF1$8$/$i$$L50UL#$G!"$h$j$$$C$=$&:a?<$/$5$($"$k56A1$G$7$+$J$$$G$7$g$&!#(B

$B$3$s$J$3$H$r8@$$$D$D$b!"$I$&$d$C$?$i!"@$3&$NIT@55A$N9=B$$r2~$a$k$3$H$,$G$-$k$N$+!"<+J,$K2?$,=PMh$k$N$+!"2?$r$9$Y$-$J$N$+$OJ,$i$J$$$7!"<+J,$,$7$F$$$k$3$H$OC1$J$k<+8JK~B-$J$N$+$bCN$l$J$$$H$$$&5?$$$r46$8$F$$$k$N$,@5D>$J$H$3$m$G$9!#$G$b!"$J$K$O$H$b$"$l!"$H$j$"$($::#!"L\$NA0$G?J9T$7$F$$$k%"%a%j%+@/I\$NJsI|967b$K$OH?BP!*$N0U;W$r$O$C$-$j<($7$?$$$H;W$$$^$9!#$=$l$O!"%F%m%j%:%`KPLG$I$3$m$+$5$i$J$k%F%m$r@8$_!"Tn$7$$?M!9$NL?$rC%$$B3$1$k$@$1$NC1$J$kK=NO9T0Y$G$"$j!"0lHV=}$D$1$i$l$k$N$O!"$?$@$G$5$(!"5l%=O"$N%"%U%,%s?/960JMh$N@oF.$d$=$N8e$NFb@o!"$=$N8e$N:.Mp$K=}$D$-HhJ@$7$-$C$F$$$k%"%U%,%s$NL1=0$G$"$k$N$O4V0c$$$J$$$N$G$9$+$i!#$b$7$+$7$?$i$=$3$K$O$5$i$K!"@PL};:6H$NMx8"$d73<{;:6H$NMx1W$N3NJ]$H$+!"$I$99u$$0U?^$bB?$+$l>/$J$+$lMm$s$G$$$k$N$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!J%"%a%j%+9qFb$N@PL}$N:N7!NL$OG/!98:$C$F$$$F!"2D:NG/?t$b$"$H(B10$BG/$/$i$$$J$s$@$=$&$G$9!K!#7k6I$N$H$3$m$=$l$O!"%F%m$KAx$&$+$b$7$l$J$$?M!9$bJsI|967b$KGx$5$l$k?M!9$b!=!=$=$7$F%F%m%j%9%H<+?H$b!=!=C/$b5_$o$J$$6rNt$J9T0Y$G$7$+$"$j$^$;$s!#(B

$B$5$i$K$$$($PJsI|967b$O!"J<;N$H$J$k%"%a%j%+$NB?$/$NI8u72!"%P%k%+%s>I8u72$N$h$&$J!K6l$7$_$K2W$^$l!"$7$+$b9q$O8J$N8m$j$bG'$a$J$1$l$PJ]>Z$b$7$J$$$H$$$&Ha7`$,7+$jJV$5$l$^$9!#$^$?B?L1B29q2H%"%a%j%+$G$O!"$3$&$$$&!V9q2H$N4m5!!W$N$H$-$K$O!"F|:"3d$r?)$C$F$$$k%^%$%N%j%F%#$[$I!V%"%a%j%+9qL1!W$H$7$F$N%"%$%G%s%F%#%F%#$K2a>j$KF10l2=$7!"@o>l$KIk$+$6$k$r$($J$/$J$k$H$$$&ITJ?Ey$J9=B$$,$"$C$?$j$7$^$9!#@oAh$O!"%"%a%j%+9qFb$NOD$_!"IT@55A$N9=B$$r$bO*9|$K8==P$5$;$k$H$$$&$o$1$G$9!#(B

$B:G8e$K!#:#D+$ND+F|?7J9$N5-;v!J%=!<%9$O%A%e!<%j%C%RH/%m%$%?!]$N@$O@D4::$N7k2L!"!VJsI|;Y;}!W$O%"%a%j%+$H%$%9%i%(%k$@$1$G!"2$=#$dFnJF$G$O(B80%$B$+$i(B90%$B$,!"IpNO9T;H$h$j$b%F%mMF5?@\Ho32$r@\E*BP>]$H$J$C$F$$$k?M!9$K$H$C$FIT9,$G$"$k$@$1$G$J$/!"K=NO$r?6$k$&?M!9<+?H$K$H$C$F$b<+$i$NB:87$rGK2u$9$kIT9,$J9T0Y$G$9!#$3$s$J$3$H$rBh;0

2001.9.23


(2)

$B:#F|$O!"(BFBI$B$,MF5?l$K$J$C$?$H$3$m$G!"$H$C$F$b8+3P$($N$"$k2hLL$G$7$?!#5nG/$N=U$KJL7o$G9T$C$?$H$-$b!"$=$3$H$D$J$,$C$F$$$k(BCopley Square$B$GGc$$J*$7$^$7$?$7!"$A$g$C$H;v7o$N@8!9$7$5$N0lC<$rHiIf463P$G46$8$F$7$^$$$^$9!#$=$&$$$($P!"$=$N;~$b!"Gq$^$C$F$?%[%F%k$N<~JU0lBS$,!"CO2<$N2P;v$GDdEE$7$F!"Mo3,CJ$N$\$C$?$3$H$,$"$j$^$7$?$,!"$"$l$b%F%m$G$O!"$H$$$&1=$,$"$j$^$7$?!#$=$NFsF|A0$K$O!"D+!"%[%F%k$G%\%dA{$.$,$"$C$F!"Hs>o3,CJ2<$C$F$k$H$-$O!"2<$+$i>CKI;N$5$s$?$A$,6n$1>e$,$C$F$/$k$H$3$m$G$7$?!#30$K=P$F<~$j$N?M$KJ9$$$?$i!VJ|2P$+$b!W$J$s$F8@$C$F$?$j$7$F!"$d$C$Q$j%"%a%j%+$OJ*A{$@$J$!$H

$B$H$3$m$G:rF|!"!V%$%9%i%`7O$N?M!9$KBP$9$k:9JL$b7c2=$9$k$+$b!W$H=q$-$^$7$?$,!"Ha$7$$$3$H$KJF9q$G$O8=

$B$5$F!";v7o$+$iFsF|$?$C$F!"%F%l%S$b$+$J$jDL>o%b!<%I$KMn$ACe$$$F$-$^$7$?!#$=$N0lJ}$G!"(BNATO$B!JKLBg@>MN>rLs5!9=!K$,=8CDE*<+1R8"9T;H$r7h$a!"F|K\$b!V%"%a%j%+$rCG8G$H$7$F;Y;}$9$k!W$H>.@te$,JsI|;Y;}!W$J$s$F$$$&%"%s%1!<%HD4::7k2L$bJsF;$5$l$F$$$^$9!#$=$l$,!"%"%a%j%+@/I\$K$H$C$F!"!JHH9T%0%k!<%W$N%j!<%@!<$H$5$l$F$$$k!K%i%G%#%s;a$r%?%j%P%s@/8"$K0z$-EO$5$;$k$?$a$N!V6<$7!W$J$N$+!"$H$K$+$/@oAh$7$?$$$N$+$OJ,$j$^$;$s!#$1$l$I$b!"BhFs@7e$,JsI|967b;Y;}!W$J$s$F$$$&$N$O$H$s$G$b$J$/LnHZ$JOC$G$9!#$*$^$1$K!VL14V?M$KHo32$,=P$F$bJsI|;?@.(B66%$B!W$J$s$F$$$&7k2L$b$"$k$=$&$G$9$+$i!"AjEv$K%"%a%j%+$O%R%9%F%j%C%/$K$J$C$F$$$k$h$&$G$9!#:#EY$b!"$-$C$HJF!&1Q73$O(B$BNt2=%&%i%sCF(B$B$r;H$&$N$G$7$g$&$7!"$b$7$bCO>e@o$b$"$l$P!"%"%U%,%s;TL1$b!"B?9q@R73$NJ<;N$?$A!=!=$?$$$F$$$OK\9q$G3d$r?)$C$F$$$k3,AX$G$7$g$&!=!=$b!"%$%i%/$d%3%=%\F1MM$N?<9o$J8e0d>I$^$G?4G[$5$l$^$9!#;v7o$NHo32l$J$i$=$&;W$&$G$7$g$&!=!=$N$O?M>p$G$9$,!"$=$&$G$J$$?M!9$^$G$=$&$J$k$N$O!"$?$@$N=8CD%R%9%F%j!<$G$7$+$J$$!#(B

$B$A$J$_$K$3$l$O!"!V9qL19q2H!W$H$$$&%U%#%/%7%g%s$,:n$j=P$9Ha7`E*$JH?1~$J$N$+$bCN$l$^$;$s!#<+J,<+?H$d2HB2!"M'?M$J$I$,:n$k!V?FL)7w!W$KB0$5$LB>@7$K$J$k$N$O5v$;$J$$$,!"E($N;TL1$O5>@7$K$J$C$F$b$$$$!W$H$$$&@~0z$-$r@8$s$G$7$^$&$N$O!"9qL19q2H$H$$$&5u9=$,$$$+$K?<$/?M!9$N0U<1$r;YG[$7$F$$$k$+$rJ*8l$C$F$$$k$h$&$K;W$($^$9!#(B

$B$3$N@N$+$i$"$k9qL19q2H$H$$$&%i%Y%k$K$h$k@~0z$-!a;TL1$NJ,CG$N>e$K!"$5$i$K>eEI$j$5$l$F$$$k$N$,!"!V0-Kb$N%$%9%i%`86M}B&<+M3@$3&!W$H$$$&M-32$J9=?^$G$9!#$=$&$d$C$F$r$rB&@$3&!W$H$$$&%i%Y%k$N$b$H$KJ,CG$5$l!"H?L\$5$;$i$l$k$3$H$K$J$C$F$7$^$$$^$9!#$=$NE@$G$O!"!V%F%m%j%9%H!WBP!V(B($B%"%i%V7w$b4^$`(B)$B9q:]$BJ,$j$d$9$$56$j$N@o@~(B$B$GJ$$$1#$=$&$H$$$&$N$,!"%V%C%7%eBgE}NN$r$O$8$a$H$9$k!V<+M3@$3&!W$N;XF3e$,JsI|;Y;}!W$H$$$&$N$b!">pJsA`:n$N0l4D$+$b$M!#!K7nJB$_$J$3$H$G$9$,!"$o$l$o$l!V9qL1!W$O!"!VJ,$j$d$9$$9=?^!W$KqY$5$l$A$c$$$1$J$$$7!"$=$l$K$h$C$F!"<+J,$?$A$,Jz$($F$$$k!V0G!W!"C/$+$rF'$_$D$V$7$F@8$-$F$$$k$H$$$&8=rM}$5$O!"$^$5$Kh$j1[$($,$?$$IT>rM}$G$"$j!"(B"calamity"$B$G$"$k$1$l$I$b!"%^%/%m$K$O!"%F%m%j%9%H$K?M:`$H;Y;}$d6&46!"0lDj$NBg5AL>J,$rM?$($F$7$^$&$h$&$JJL$NHa;4$J>u67$r3HBg:F@8;:$7!"J|CV$9$l$P$$$D$+C/$+$,%F%m$N5>@7e$K>h$C$+$C$F$o$l$o$l$O@8$-$F$$$k$N$G$9$+$i!#>/$J$/$H$b!"?M!9$N0%$7$_$dE\$j!"6l$7$_$dF1K&0&$J$I!V?M>p!W$r$"$*$jN)$F!"??

$B$b$&0l$D!#!V$3$l$O%F%m$G$J$/!"?7$7$$%9%?%$%k$N@oAh$@!W$H$$$&$3$H$,!"%F%l%S$G$b$$$m$s$JO@

$BDI5-#1!'(B
$B$5$-$[$IJ,$C$?$N$G$9$,!"KG0W%;%s%?!<%S%k$N;v7o$GF|K\?M9TJ}ITL@A0$HG/Np!"$=$l$+$i6P$a@h$r?7J9$G8+$F!V$^$5$+!&!&!&!W$H;W$C$F$$$?$N$G$9$,!"%F%l%S%K%e!<%9$G4i

$BDI5-#2!'(B(9/15)
$B$=$&$$$($P!#@hF|$"$k=82q$K9T$C$?$H$-!":#$O!J3N$+!KFnJF4X78$N;Y1g!&5_:Q3hF0$r$7$F$$$k%Z%k!Z7t%^%s!J%&!<%^%s!K!=!=%0%m!<%P%j%h$j1[$($F!"K\Mh$N!V@o@~!W$K!J$b$A$m$sCG8G$H$7$FHsK=NOE*!&J?OBE*$K!*!K2C$o$C$F$$$/$J$s$F$$$&8D?M$N4q@W!=!=F;M}$8$c$J$/$F!"$"$/$^$G!V4q@W!W$G$9$,!=!=$NJ*8l$,$"$C$?$i$J$!!"$H!"7k9=!"KM$O??7u$KL4A[$7$F$$$^$9!#(B

2001.9.13


(1)

$BKM$N@lLg$N2J3X5;=Q7k$9$kOCBj$G$O$J$$$G$9$,!"$H$s$G$b$J$$$3$H$,5/$-$F$7$^$$$^$7$?!#%"%a%j%+F1;~B?H/%F%m!#$O$C$-$j$$$C$F$3$l$O?7$7$$!V@oAh!W$N%9%?%$%k$NEP>l$G$7$g$&!#(B

$B$G$b!"$A$g$C$H9M$($F$_$k$H!":#2s$NHH9T$BNt2=%&%i%sCF;HMQ$K$h$k8e0d>I$N?<9o$5(B$B$J$I!"%"%a%j%+(B($B$*$h$SB>$N@h?J9q(B)$B$K$h$k@$3&$N5>@7e$NL14V?M$,;`$s$@$H$$$&?d7W$b$"$j$^$9$7!"$=$N8e$N%$%i%/$X$N7P:QIu:?$G$O!"0eLtIJITB-$G!"Nt2=%&%i%sCF$N1F6A$H8+$i$l$kGr7lIB$d%,%s$K6l$7$`;R6!$?$A$,!"2?$N$B$J$i$:$B!W$@$H$$$&LL$O3N$+$K$"$k$s$G$9$h$M!"O*9|$K!#$"$k$$$O!"%0%m!<%P%j%@7$b?<9o$G$7$g$&!#%$%9%i%(%k!]%Q%l%9%A%JLdBj$b$"$^$j$K:,?<$$!#(B

$B$b$A$m$s$@$+$i$H$$$C$F!":#2s$N;v7o$GB?Bg$J?ML?$,5>@7$K$J$C$?$3$H$NBg:a$OHy?P$?$j$H$bD">C$7$K$J$j$^$;$s$,!"MW$O!"0lHL$K$O8+$($K$/$$!"$b$7$/$O$"$^$j$KF|>oE*$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$F$$$k$@$1$G!"7P:QE*$K$b73;vE*$K$b@$3&$O>o$K@oAh>uBV$K$"$j!";~@^!"%F%m$H$$$&8+$($d$9$$$+$?$A$G@o@~$,2D;k2=$9$k$@$1$@$H$$$&$3$H!"$=$7$F!"$3$NF|>oE*@oAh>uBV$r:n$j=P$7$F$$$k$N$O!"%"%a%j%+$rCf?4$H$9$kOD$s$@%0%m!<%P%k7P:Q$J$N$@$H$$$&8=

$B$=$l$K$7$F$b!"1GA|$r8+$F$b1G2h$_$?$$$@$7(B($B$?$V$s%$%^%I%-$NFC;#$N$[$&$,$9$4$$$G$7$g$&$7(B)$B!"$J$s$@$+%j%"%j%F%#$rDO$_$+$M$F$7$^$$$^$9!#$3$N=PMh;v$N!V0UL#!W$,$I$l$[$IBg$-$$$N$+!"$I$l$[$I@$3&$K$H$C$F!"$o$l$o$l$K$H$C$F?<9o$J$b$N$J$N$+!"Hf$Y$&$kA0Nc$,$J$$$@$1$KB,$j$+$M$F$7$^$&!&!&!&(B

$B$3$l$>$^$5$K!VNr;KE*;v7o!W$N(B$BNr;K@-(B$B$=$N$b$N$J$N$G$7$g$&!#(B

$B=PMh;v$=$N$b$N$O!"F|>o$N0UL#$NEbFM$J!VGK$lL\!W$H$7$F$^$:8=$o$l!"$=$N8=

$B%V%C%7%eBgE}NN$r$O$8$a@$3&$N$O!"3'!V<+M3$HL1/$J$/$H$b!"$3$N5!$K>h$8$F$=$&$$$&F0$-$r@5Ev2=$7$?$$I!B)$N9S$$%*%8%5%s$?$A$N@<$,$^$9$^$96/$/$J$k$G$7$g$&!#JF9qFb$O$b$A$m$s!"@$3&3F9q$G%$%9%i%`7O$N?M!9$KBP$9$k:9JL$b7c2=$9$k$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!#$b$A$m$sF|K\$G$b!#4V$,$$$$$H$$$&$+0-$$$H$$$&$+!"$J$s$H@P86El5~ETCN;v$O%o%7%s%H%s$KBZ:_Cf$G$7$?$7!"5"9q8e$NH`$NH/8@$O$^$9$^$9%J%7%g%J%j%9%F%#%C%/$G?M

$B!V@$3&6292!W$H$+!"8+$($d$9$$=PMh;v$N5"7k$,Bg$7$?$3$H$J$$$H$7$F$b!"$=$&$$$&8+$($K$/$$$H$3$m$G$N5"7k$O!"8+$($K$/$$$@$1$KM>7W$K62$$$G$9!#(B

$B$=$l$K$7$F$b(B11$B7n$N$O$8$a$K3X2q$G%\%9%H%s9T$/M=Dj$J$N$G$9$,!"$&!<$`!"62$$$J$!!&!&!&(B

2001.9.12

HOME